In 2009 there was a brief flurry of attention given to a possible link between a multi-state "chain" of charter schools (Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Missouri, Nevada, New , Jersey, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, and Wisconsin) & the "Gulen Movement".
http://charterschoolscandals.blogspot.com/2010/06/sonoran-science-academy-tucson.htmlhttp://www.turkishforum.com.tr/en/content/2009/06/23/fetullah-gulens-schools-are-all-over-the-us/***
The Gulen movement is reportedly a loosely organized, world-wide association of institutions founded by followers of Fethullah Gulen, a Turkish-born Islamic scholar & now a US resident.
It's difficult to know what exactly Gulen's about. His own website & those of his followers speak of peace & love; his detractors have another story:
"Fethullah's aim is the Islamization of Turkish nationality and the Turcification of Islam in foreign countries..." Balcı explained, "He wants to revive the link between state, religion, and society."
Gulen followers are said to control the Turkish police as well:
http://www.newsweek.com/2009/05/15/behind-turkey-s-witch-hunt.htmlGulen himself is currently living in Pennsylvania, having left Turkey under a cloud (Turkish courts brought suit against him for trying to take over the secular Turkish state).
http://www.newsweek.com/2009/05/15/behind-turkey-s-witch-hunt.htmlGiven some of his pro-buisiness, pro-west pronouncements & the apparent ease with which his followers established their private network of US charter schools, another thesis can't be overlooked: that Gulen & his movement are, in some part, US-sponsored. I came to this idea without help, but I'm not the first person to do so:
http://www.turkishforum.com.tr/en/content/2010/05/16/the-gulen-movement-plays-big-in-washington/Magnolia Schools personnel's apparently solid links with various universities also indicate some solid domestic backers.
In this regard, it's interesting that bans on Gulen-associated schools have been established in Uzbekistan & Russia, & that there was an official inquiry into the movement & its schools in the Netherlands.
***
Whatever he & his followers' real motivations, the world-wide empire-building aspect of the Gulen movement is impossible to miss: it owns banks & other financial institutions, think-tanks, TV & other media, lobbyists -- and schools.
"The core of Gülen's network is his educational institutions. His school network is impressive. Nurettin Veren, Gülen's right-hand man for thirty-five years, estimated that some 75 percent of Turkey's two million preparatory school students are enrolled in Gülen institutions. He controls thousands of top-tier secondary schools, colleges, and student dormitories throughout Turkey, as well as private universities, the largest being Fatih University in Istanbul.
Outside Turkey, his movement runs hundreds of secondary schools and dozens of universities in 110 countries worldwide."
http://www.meforum.org/2045/fethullah-gulens-grand-ambition***
My interest was initially sparked when, researching something else, I came across a network of California charters which all had Turkish principals & boards. The students took a lot of trips to Turkey: field trips, spring break trips, etc.
These were the Magnolia Schools.
http://www.magnoliacharterschools.org/I thought the all-Turkish principals were a bit unusual -- in schools which were reportedly majority Latino. Invetigating further, I found board members & execs linked to other organizations. For example, Suleyman Bahceci.
At the time, Bahceci was CEO of the Magnolia Education & Research Foundation (the "non-profit" management organization that runs the Magnolia chain) & a member of the Magnolia board.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:VQ-6FJDEqCcJ:issuu.com/msa4news/docs/reflections__winter_2010_+suleyman+bahceci&cd=22&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=usMore on Bahceci:
-- Graduate of Orta Dorgu Technical University (Turkey) BS 1992, MS 1995
-- Graduate of U. Texas, Austin MA Computational Chem 1997, PhD 1999
-- Listed on one of his bios as developer/founder of Austin TX charter schools
-- Only non-education job listed is 2 years with the biotech company, Exelixis
-- Former member Board of Directors, Accord Institute
http://www.google.com/#q=%22suleyman+bahceci%22+accord+institute&hl=en&start=10&sa=N&fp=e73b16faf0160c30-- Board of Directors, Willow Education:
Willow runs runs tutoring services in the Oakland public schools. It also runs Baytech (Bay Area Technology School, a grade 6-12 charter specializing in math/sciences that also takes regular field trips to Turkey).
Baytech opened using a 2003 $450K grant from the state of California -- a "charter school start-up grant." Willow also, "with the help of more than $200,000 donations," built "one of the best state-of-the art Science and Computer labs in the district."
And California's funding another "start-up" grant so Willow can open another school: this time for $405K.
http://we-team.org/about/about.htmlhttp://www.baytechschool.org/j/Newspaper accounts connect Bahceci to at least one Turkish-run charter in another state. The connection came to light in the wake of complaints from parents enrolled in Turkish-run schools in Arizona & Utah.
Bahceci reportedly made a personal loan of $30K to Utah's "Beehive Science & Technology" charter. Other Magnolia schools & Accord Institute personnel also loaned that school money. There are other business ties between the California & Utah schools & institutes as well:
http://www.sltrib.com/education/ci_12855515Although the connections were denied in the news accounts, the Accord Institute's own newsletter calls the Sonoran Science Academies (Tucson, Phoenix), the Magnolia schools, Baytech, & the Coral Science Academy (Reno NV) "member schools" of the Accord Institute, & notes its "winter institute" for students & staff in California, Nevada, Arizona & Utah.
http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:lfH08hPPhQ8J:www.accordeducation.org/accordquarterly/accord_quarterly_volume1_issue1.pdf+%22accord+institute%22+grant&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESjIqVDvV3-Av5_OivcXMQUy50rAcIWLFpTsx_YLWi55uUHBvtuDFGCMyAR0HazuQYHRGi29Zh_yMUpEpbbb9jOFtZfavJCSZJkHsAb5lR-IkQ5iRBljVnkT7Fn49YR-u01y-Q-A&sig=AHIEtbSTLekP9WJTEfGO8d6T9cHJ3T4ebgH1B visas:
Another interesting point about the Magnolia schools & other schools where Turks predominate as board members & principals is their fondness for H1B visas:
Here's the Magnolia Education & Research Foundation: 77 H1B apps since 2007:
-- including 9 requests for English or English as a Second Language teachers (since Magnolia schools are reportedly majority Latino -- why do they need Turkish ESL teachers to teach hispanic kids english?)
Not to mention requests for computer science teachers (lots of unemployed computer scientists in the US right now...), history teachers (none in the US?), etc.
http://www.myvisajobs.com/H1B_Visa_Employer.aspx?N=Magnolia+Educational+and+Research+Foundation&E=799321&OG=Education&SO=All&Z=90248&Y=Allhttp://www.myvisajobs.com/H1B_Visa_Employer.aspx?N=Magnolia+Educational+and+Research+Foundation&E=799321&OG=Education&SO=All&Z=90247&Y=Allhttp://www.myvisajobs.com/H1B_Visa_Employer.aspx?N=Dialog+Foundation+dba+Magnolia+Science+Academy&E=333524&OG=Education&SO=All&Z=91335&Y=AllHere's the Accord Institute: 16 apps since 2007
http://www.myvisajobs.com/H1B_Visa_EmpList.aspx?E=accord%20institute&OG=Education&SO=All&Y=AllWillow Education/Baytech: 19 applications since 2007: 7 science teachers, 2 computer teachers, 2 computer/network administrators, 4 math teachers, etc.
http://www.myvisajobs.com/H1B_Visa_Employer.aspx?N=Willow+Education+(dba+Bay+Area+Technology+School)&E=599262&OG=All&SO=All&WC=Oakland&WS=CA&Y=All
For general interest, here's a Texas charter school network that's largely Turkish in its upper echelons: The Cosmos Foundation which runs Texas' Harmony chain of charters: 1157 applications 2001-2010, 280 of them in 2009.
That makes it the 252nd-biggest sponsor of H1B's in the US.
http://www.myvisajobs.com/Visa-Sponsor/Cosmos-Foundation-dba-Harmony-Science-Academy/131451.htmThe Harmony schools have 32 campuses in TX, including 3 in Austin. I've found no evidence of any connection to the California Magnolia Schools or to Mr. Bahceci. However, math & science & science olympiads also feature prominently at the Harmony schools, & the timing of the schools' foundation (approx 2000-2002) is right.
***
Schools are always institutions of "indoctrination," whether or not we consider that indoctrination in a positive or negative light.
In my opinion, one of the disturbing aspects of the charter school movement is that private parties can establish & use school networks under the radar for political/economic purposes which are largely unknown to the general public -- & using public money to do so.
So reports that Gulen-affiliated schools are the LARGEST NETWORK OF CHARTER SCHOOLS IN THE US are troubling. As it would be if it were a private corporation, the Southern Baptists, the Moonies, the Scientologists, the Soka Gakkai, Iran's Tudeh party, the communists, the fascists, or the US Republican or Democratic Parties running them.
Particularly if these private entities were creaming off young students particularly interested in science & math, allowing them to identify & direct top students early.
If you prefer unity to balkanization, that is. If you prefer public disclosure to hidden operations & finances, that is. If you prefer democracy to oligarchy, that is.