Military Testing 'Ink Spot' Strategy in Afghanistan

[bigtree]

... for anyone who imagined they're ready to let go of their Afghan misadventure.


from NYT: http://schott.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/16/ink-spot-strategy/

November 16, 2009 - A military maneuver whereby counter-insurgency and reconstruction efforts spread outwards from secured key areas – as an ink spot expands on paper.

Reporting from Afghanistan for The Washington Times, David Axe revealed: (http://washingtontimes.com/news/2009/nov/12/us-tests-ink-spot-strategy-in-afghanistan/)

U.S. forces are testing a modified strategy dubbed “ink spots” in which coalition forces pick certain districts to flood with reconstruction projects and permanently defend from Taliban insurgents.

In Logar province, 50 miles south of Kabul, a newly arrived contingent of U.S. and Czech troops is putting the ink-spot idea into practice. …

Gen. Stanley A. McChrystal ordered U.S. commanders to withdraw their troops from remote areas of Afghanistan in September. Rather than attempting to control the whole country, troops will instead concentrate counter-insurgency efforts on key population centers, expanding slowly from these secured areas.

According to Axe:

In a recent article in Small Wars Journal, Maj. Mehar Omar Khan, a Pakistani officer attending the U.S. Army’s staff college, advocated “creating and building examples” in a handful of Afghan districts. Above all, “don’t try to arrest the sea,” Maj. Khan advised. Instead, “create islands.”

This has worked before. The U.S. Marine Corps embraced the ink-spot strategy in western Iraq in the middle years of the Iraq war. Gradually improving security resulting from that approach provided the basis for Gen. David H. Petraeus’ later population-centric “surge” strategy.

Afghanistan, however, presents a different challenge. Unlike Iraq, its population is mostly rural and dispersed among small villages. Also, Afghanistan is more populous, and there are far fewer coalition and native troops in Afghanistan than in Iraq.


(Also known as an oil spot or ink blot strategy, this approach was explored by the British in Malaya in the 1950s. For further discussion, see this entry on the Double-Tongued Dictionary (good read): http://www.doubletongued.org/index.php/dictionary/oil_spot_strategy/)

[Tierra_y_Libertad]

1. They called that strategy "Fortified Villages" in Vietnam. Didn't work there either.

[dixiegrrrrl]

5. the word "pacification" also comes to mind.

or am I getting that confused with some other imperial war?
Definitely a modern day "fort building" exercise.

[Cessna Invesco Palin]

12. With one major difference:

In Vietnam, creation of the strategic hamlets involved forced relocation.

[alfredo]

2. Interesting. Still, our soldiers are dying for a corrupt regime and that is wrong.

[tekisui]

3. How many ways can we continue a lost war?

[NNN0LHI]

4. NGO's need to be doing the reconstruction projects

Afghans are not stupid people. They see the inevitable waste and corruption on these military projects. It makes them as sick as us to see it.

Then when they realize most of the money is wasted paying mercenaries to terrorize them into capitulating it really pisses them off.

It wouldn't make us none too happy if someone was doing it to us either.

Don

[petronius]

6. After eight years, we really should be past the strategy "testing" phase

[arcadian]

10. +1

[Solly Mack]

7. Déjà vu

[arcadian]

8. That's some expensive ink.

[bigtree]

9. red ink

methinks

[arcadian]

11. I was just thinking that

was gonna edit my post but you summed it up perfectly.

[optimator]

13. waste of time

waste of money.
waste of lives.