Eugene Robinson: U.S., Afghanistan's drug trade, and a fog of moral ambiguity

[bigtree]

11-3-09

U.S. can't justify entanglement with Afghan drug trade

WASHINGTON — The opium poppy was introduced to Afghanistan more than 2,300 years ago by the armies of Alexander the Great. His forces were eventually driven out, like those of every would-be conqueror since. The poppy has proved more tenacious.

On Wednesday, The New York Times reported that the CIA has been making regular payments to a suspected major figure in the Afghan opium trade: Ahmed Wali Karzai, the brother of President Hamid Karzai. The newspaper quoted sources alleging that Ahmed Wali Karzai — who denies any involvement in the drug business — collects "huge" fees from traffickers for allowing trucks loaded with drugs to cross bridges he controls in the southern part of the country.

So is it our policy to attack the Afghan drug trade while we also line the pockets of one of its reputed kingpins? Who is going to explain this to the families of (DEA) agents Leamon, Michael and Weston (killed in a helicopter crash in western Afghanistan)?

Afghanistan's status as a narco-superpower is another reason why President Obama would be wrong to deepen U.S. involvement. Opium is the one booming sector of the Afghan economy: Poppy fields in the south and west of the country produce the raw material for an estimated 90 percent of the world's heroin. Money from the opium trade supports the resurgent Taliban, which is fighting to expel U.S. and NATO forces. Therefore, a blow against the drug business is a blow against the enemy.

Except when it isn't. Except when the "good guys" who are supposed to be our allies — and many of the Afghan citizens a counterinsurgency strategy would try to protect — are dependent on the drug trade as well. Except when the corruption that is an intrinsic element of the drug business not only blurs the line between friend and foe, but also obscures the difference between right and wrong in a thick fog of moral ambiguity.

read more: http://www.southbendtribune.com/article/20091103/Opinion/911030367/1065/Opinion