Leading article: End of an empire?
Starbucks is bottom of high street coffee test Thursday, 24 January 2008
Starbucks was named after the first mate in Moby Dick, but of late the coffee chain must have begun to feel like the great white hunted whale itself. Last year, a Starbucks branch that had opened in Beijing's Forbidden City was forced to close, at about the same time as accusations of cultural imperialism were reaching a climax. The company's sales have been sliding and its quality control has reportedly declined. And now, according to a survey by the consumer magazine Which?, Starbucks is producing the worst coffee on the high street.
Accusations of cultural imperialism are one thing but claims that your main product stinks cannot be easily brushed off. Perhaps the most damaging harpoon for Starbucks is the popular belief that it is no longer cool. What began as a rather hip venture from Seattle has, in the eyes of many, become a bloated corporate monster. Crushing opposition, ripping the heart out of high streets and helping to reduce our lives to a bland uniformity may be a successful business strategy but it does not make a company loved. Satirists now target the chain without mercy. Not even the signing of Sir Paul McCartney to the Starbucks record label can reverse that kind of negative publicity.
We should not be surprised. Starbuck has been an astonishing business success story. But any organisation that expands very quickly (particularly in the catering trade) will inevitably lose touch with its founding ethos.
Enemies of Starbucks should not be celebrating yet, however. The coffee chain could still entrench its position. Remember that Herman Melville's leviathan escaped the clutches of Captain Ahab. So, too, could Starbucks.
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/leading-articles/leading-article-end-of-an-empire-773068.html