Uh, no. Ed Shultz is wrong. This is not the Conservative F-911.

[tjwash]

I'm sorry, but that's a fucking insult to Michael Moore and F-911.

First of all, F-911 was a documentary. Moore used real news clips and talked to the real people. He had the guts to go confront the real politicians. He used real events, and presented them in the format that he is known best for. He has been doing the same thing since "Roger and Me"

Path is a fucking movie. It's paid actors, it's written with a script, and it is based loosely on events that transpired with a blatant neo-con propaganda slant. Does anyone think that Cyrus Nowrasteh and the rest of these chicken shit screen writers and producers would actually have the guts to walk up to Bill Clinton and confront him about ignoring terrorists like he accuses him of? Or Madeleine Albright? Or Sandy Berger? Hell these chickenshit bastards don't even want to let them WATCH it must less actually show some stones and act like a real documentary film maker.

And just in case anyone forgot, the neo-cons already came out with their attempt at a rebuttal to F-911 using a documentary format and facts. Dollars to donuts I'll bet only 1 in 10 americans actually know what it was really called because it was so weak, and lacking in any real content.

[wyldwolf]

1. no, he's correct

This movie is to conservatives what F9/11 was to the left.

[tjwash]

10. They had their rebuttal documentary.

It was called Faith in the White House. And no one remembers it because it sucked.

[Drewskie]

43. ...

Hmm thought you might of meant Celsius 41.11.

The title did'nt come to me til now.

[SmokingJacket]

11. But in CONTENT, the OP is right.

F 9/11 was a documentary.

[Lindacooks]

26. That's right.

And this path to 9/11 mockumentary shit probably IS a "documentary" to repukes, because it's full of the lies they love so much.

I mean, how on earth could you face yourself in the bathroom mirror (maybe that's Rove's secret - he doesn't have an image) without lying to yourself constantly?

[WinkyDink]

20. Don't kid yourself; Conservatives know full well it's a pack of lies.

It's simply that they feel lies are more important for their interests than truth.

[sandnsea]

21. Except Disney bailed on F 9/11

And paid $20,000,000 for this piece of crap to be broadcast on OUR airwaves as if it were an objective true story. That's the difference.

[dogday]

30. But ABC refused to show "Ours" because they said

it was too close to elections, and it was too political.... Go figure :shrug:

[OzarkDem]

38. With an exception

F-911 was factual, Path contains quite a bit of false information.

No one will argue that a lot of people disagreed with what Michael Moore said and depicted in his documentary, but he told the truth.

[rman]

44. It seems that's not what Shultz is saying

"Path to 9-11 is the Conservative F-911"

versus

"This movie is to conservatives what F9/11 was to the left"

[leftofthedial]

2. other than support for workers,

Ed Schultz is always wrong

[Jeanette in FL]

3. Isn't that the truth

I can't wait until Sirius replaces Ed Shultz with Mike Malloy. Wouldn't that be great.

[leftofthedial]

5. that would rock

[driver8]

17. I have always stood up for Ed Schultz because he supports unions and

labor.

I am going to have a tough time standing up for him now.

[The_Casual_Observer]

4. In order to make a case against Clinton, they had to make up an

event that never happened. To make a case against bush one need only grab the nearest video tape of him . They know that.

[EstimatedProphet]

6. Call him and tell him, just like you told us

because you did a good job of explaining the difference here.

[Pharaoh]

7. Ed Shulltz is a DLC shill

[KyndCulture]

13. DING DING

Fuck him... I can't stand him.

[Drewskie]

19. DLC

[wryter2000]

8. Turn Schultz off

You'll be glad you did.

[howmad1]

12. Amen to that!

What a friggin fat blowhard. He's bucking to be in the same league with Limpballs.

[tjwash]

15. I know. I already did.

I always last about three minutes into one of his monologues, and shut him off. I turn it back on when it's time for Randi though.

[AtomicKitten]

9. Schultz is a moron on this issue.

F9-11 was factual, this mockudrama is fiction.

[KyndCulture]

14. You coulda stopped at:

he's a moron.

[AtomicKitten]

22. almost no one is bereft of value IMO

I disagree with Schultz on many issues, on thus vehemently because his analogy is faulty, but he is a strong worker/labor advocate and comes at BushCo pretty strong.

I don't like summarily kicking someone to the curb just because I don't agree with them. He is respectful in his discourse and I appreciate that.

[BuyingThyme]

18. Moron.

[laststeamtrain]

16. Moore's film did NOT go out over the publicly owned airwaves;

Moore's film was NOT promoted as a teaching tool by Scholastic;
that's two differences.
Replace all radio entertainers with a good book on tape. A recent one. Not 1984.

[helderheid]

28. Moore's wasn't FICTION either.

[Horse with no Name]

23. I can't listen to him

He is nothing but a RW hack--regardless of what he claims to be.

[B Calm]

24. My god, boy do I ever miss Malloy. He was the real thing!

[The Revolution]

25. That sounds right

I mean, the right-wing version of F-911 wouldn't be a factual documentary, it would be a ball of lies designed to mislead people, which is what 'Path' is. The right-wing version of F-911 wouldn't follow our standards (evidence, truth, etc.) It would follow their own (lies, wild accusations, etc). So this is their version of F-911.

There have been other 'conservative F-911s' before, but this one is actually generating some controversy, while the others were just completely ignored by pretty much everyone. So calling the the conservative F-911 sounds right to me.

[Pharaoh]

29. But this is being broadcast on ABC!

Not a movie you have to go to or a dvd you have to buy!

[Leopolds Ghost]

34. How dare you! ;-)

Geez, people, enough with the Ed-hate. Whatever happened to tolerance of differing opinions and all that good stuff?

[helderheid]

27. I think Ed is a mole.

[Ignacio Upton]

31. F-9/11 Was fact, while Path to 9/11 is a bald-faced lie

n/t.

[RandiRhodesArchives]

32. F. Ed Shitz!!!!!

I have nothing good to say about a "man" who would call Randi Rhodes "Radio Slut". Shame on him! Sick of "Rush Lite"?! Then how about the REAL deal...RANDI!

INTERNET: http://www.airamericaradio.com/audio
Albany/Corvallis/Salem, OR: 990 KTHH
Albuquerque, NM: 1350 KABQ
Anchorage, AK: 1080 KUDO
Ann Arbor, MI: 1290 WLBY
Asheville, NC: 880 WPEK
Austin, TX: 1600 KOKE
Barstow, CA: 1230 KSZL
Baton Rouge, LA: 1380 WYNK
Binghamton, NY: 1360 WYOS
Boston, MA: 1430 WXKS
Brattleboro, VT: 1490 WKVT
Buffalo, NY: WHLD 1270
Burlington, VT/Plattsburgh, NY: 1070 WTWK
Cedar Rapids/Iowa City/Waterloo, IA: 800 KXIC
Charlottesville, VA: 1450 WVAX
Chicago, IL: 850 WCPT
Cincinnati, OH: 1530 WCKY
Cleveland/Akron/Canton, OH: 1520 WJMP
Columbus, OH: 1230 WPTG
Corpus Christi, TX: 1150 KCCT
Dallas/Ft. Worth, TX: 910 KXEB
Davenport, IA (aka Quad Cities): 1270 WKBF
Denver/Boulder, CO: 760 KKZN
Detroit, MI: 1310 WDTW
Duluth/Superior, MN: 1490 KQDS
El Paso, TX: 1650 KHRO
Eugene/Springfield, OR: 1450 KOPT
Framingham, MA: 1200 WKOX
Fresno, CA: 790 KFPT
Grand Rapids, MI: 1230 WTKG
Greenfield, MA: 1240 WHMQ
Honolulu, HI: 1500 KUMU
Huntington, WV: 930 WRVC
Ithaca, NY: 1470 WNYY
Key West/Key Largo, FL: 1500 WKIZ
Lafayette, LA: 1490 KEUN
Little Rock, AR: 1380 KDXE
Los Angeles, CA: 1150 KXTA
Madison, WI: 92.1 WXXM
Memphis, TN: 680 WWTQ
Miami/Ft. Lauderdale, FL: 940 WINZ
Minneapolis/St. Paul, MN: 950 KTNF
Missoula, MT: 105.9 KKNS
Monterey/Santa Cruz/Salinas, CA: 1340 KOMY
New Haven, CT: 1300 WAVZ
New Orleans, LA: 1350 WSMB
New York, NY: 1600 WWRL
Northampton, MA: 1400 WHMP
Palm Springs, CA: 1340 KWXY
Phoenix, AZ: 1480 KPHX
Portland, ME: 870 WLVP
Portland, OR: 620 KPOJ
Providence, RI: 920 WHJJ
Reno, NV: 1230 KJFK
Riverside/San Bernadino, CA: 1050 KCAA
Rochester, NY: 950 WROC
Sacramento, CA: 1320 KCTC
San Antonio/Victoria, TX: 103.1 KTXX
San Diego, CA: 1360 KLSD
San Francisco/San Jose, CA: 960 KQKE
San Luis Obispo, CA: 1340 KYNS
Santa Barbara, CA: 1340 KTLK
Santa Fe, NM: 1260 KTRC
Seattle, WA: 1090 KPTK
Sheridan/Ranchester/Buffalo, WY: 93.7 KYTI
Spokane, WA: 1280 KAQQ
Springfield, MA: 1600 WHNP
Taos, NM: 1340 KVOT
Traverse City/Petoskey/Cheboygan, MI: 750 WWKK
Washington, DC: 1260 WWRC
West Palm Beach / Stuart / Boca Raton, FL: 1290 WJNO

More info, go to & bookmark:

http://www.TheRandiRhodesShow.com

* and *

http://www.RandiRhodesArchives.com

[wryter2000]

35. Welcome to DU

:hi:

[wryter2000]

36. Oh, and hey...

I would LOVE to listen to Randi on KQKE, but they delay her by four freaking hours. One so the morning guys don't have to get up too early and three so they can play Schultz. I'm back to streaming (which, unfortunately, is difficult for me on Mondays).

[nashville_brook]

33. schultz is running as an "independent" on this issue

:D

[Kitsune]

37. Ed Shultz, uninformed?!

I'm shocked, shocked I tell you. :sarcasm:

[tuvor]

39. That sounds like a right-wing talking point.

Gives this docufairytale a certain amount of legitimacy.

[B Calm]

40. He's a right-winger!

[tuvor]

41. Sorry, I thought we were talking about an AAR personality.

I'm not able to listen to the station that much.

[B Calm]

45. We are.. AAR is slowly turning into another right-wing network for

more advertisement profits!

[MzNov]

42. You are absolutely correct. F-911 was truth!!!

I heard Ed blowbag Shultz today and thought the exact same thing.

The guy does more harm than good ferrchrissakes.

I wish I could get someone else at this time slot, but I have no choice. I tune in for a few minutes before Randi every day.

He makes me crazy.

:crazy: