The 65 Percent Solution: 100 Percent Deception

[proud2BlibKansan]

The 65 Percent Solution: 100 Percent Deception

The "65 percent solution" is a scheme being promoted nationally by a Washington, D.C.-based organization called First Class Education (FCE). FCE's goal is to enact legislation or pass a ballot measure in every state mandating that school districts spend 65 percent of their budgets on "classroom instruction."

Proponents claim that the measure will reduce school "waste" while improving student achievement. They also claim that it will increase money for schools without requiring an increase in overall spending or taxes.

In reality, however, the 65 percent initiative is no solution at all. Rather, it is 100 percent deception, a simplistic and arbitrary gimmick that will actually harm schools and students.

At the heart of the measure's flaws is its narrow and misleading definition of "classroom instruction." This definition is arbitrarily based on the definition of "Instruction Expenditures" used by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), a federal agency that collects and reports data on school district spending. For accounting and descriptive purposes, NCES divides spending data into broad categories such as instruction, student support services and instruction support services. The agency refrains, however, from making any value judgments about what percentage of school budgets should go to each category, nor has it ever intended its categories to be the basis for making public policy.

And this is for good reason. While NCES's "instruction" definition includes the costs of teachers, teacher assistants and most classroom supplies, it excludes staff and program costs for numerous essential services that support and sustain instruction. Services left out by the definition include libraries, guidance counselors, school nurses and healthcare, professional development, food and nutrition, transportation, custodial work and building maintenance and security—i.e., the very services that make classroom learning possible in the first place.

more . . . http://www.aft.org/topics/65percent/index.htm

[flashl]

1. K/R nt

[tbyg52]

2. Another case of people who have probably never set foot in a classroom

except as a student thinking they know just what to do. I'd like to see education law made strictly by those who have at one point or another actually taught for a living.....

[ulysses]

3. you going to crosspost to GD or shall I?

We need to get information like this out of the blackboard dungeon and where people can see it. Thanks!

[proud2BlibKansan]

5. Be my guest

:)

[LWolf]

4. I was hearing about this 3 years ago,

when I moved out of state.

One more way to make sure excellent education for all is never fully funded.