And in Harlem, the most likely African American voters are churchgoing people, middle-aged, working-class. They do not like language like "punk ass bitch." Maybe it's different in Ohio. And as far as I know, the registration rate among young African Americans likely to be driving "pimped out cars with fine women" blasting a song with lyrics like that is something under 10 percent, depending on how you define that demographic statistically. In any case, it's way under the number who are incarcerated, which is one reason we must win this election.
I'm not knocking the basic point you are making, at all. But I'd be a lot happier to see a "pimped out" car handing out voter registration forms. To the extent that the constituency you would reach with "punk ass bitch" would respond to electoral politics, they already hate Bush plenty. So the question is: does an expression of rage motivate voters while not alienating equally important already-motivated voters (all those church ladies in gorgeous hats I see on Sundays, for example, who vote at something like 75-80 percent levels).
As for "rednecks," again, it depends how you define the demographic. Peel off the Christian fundies, and you have a lot of decent working-class people in this country who vote republican out of fear and sometimes ignorance. I spent years in that milieu (professional country musician, actually) and my gut tells me Shrub's support is very brittle except among the religious wingnuts.
But in that demo, there's almost nothing to lose and everything to gain by using anger as a motivator to flip people over to our side. The right has used anger to mobilize their base, including "rednecks" (I have been using the term in jest, and I don't mean people who use the N word, by the way; don't stereotype people as stereotypers!) for years. Listen to "Takin' My Country Back" with open ears, and that's the sound of a conversion experience.
Good, and interesting, debate. I don't think it's either/or. I love a good anti-Bush rant as much as anyone. I like a good nasty hip hop cut as much as anyone. It ain't my music, but I can get it. KRS-One has had interesting things to say on the subject of profanity, motivation, and politics in rap. Rage has an important place, but sometimes anger is better served ice cold.
RCM
Best. Anti-Bush. Country. Song. Ever.
http://www.takinmycountryback.com/