But some are working on a better solution.
http://money.cnn.com/2005/10/28/news/economy/windfall_tax/Oil industry under fireSoaring earnings prompt calls for a windfall profit tax, but will big oil end up having to pay?
October 28, 2005: 2:51 PM EDT
By Chris Isidore, CNN/Money senior writer
NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - Soaring energy prices and record profits for big oil companies have sparked a wave of public outrage in the United States that's led all the way to Capitol Hill.
>SNIP<
Sen. Byron Dorgan has introduced a three-year tax of 50 percent for any profit oil companies make for oil sold above $40 a barrel.
But even the North Dakota Democrat admits it's an uphill battle for the bill.
"This is not a very hospitable political environment to challenge the oil industry," Dorgan told CNN/Money. "We have a president and vice president who come from the oil industry and they're not interested in doing anything that runs counter to the interests of major integrated oil companies."
But Dorgan said he's sensing some growing support for a tax across the aisle.
* * * * * *
Other views: In North Dakota we use twice as much gasoline per person as New Yorkers do. Why?By Sen. Byron Dorgan,
Published Sunday, November 06, 2005
>snip<
There’s no free market for oil. OPEC oil ministers sit around a table, colluding about supply and price. The big integrated oil companies (bigger and stronger as a result of mega mergers) face less and less price competition. Finally, the futures market is a grand bazaar of speculators. There’s no free market there – only an unfair process that gives record profits to the major integrated oil companies and record pain to consumers.
We should enact a windfall profits tax to recapture those excessive profits and use the funds to make rebates to consumers hurting from these prices.
My proposal applies only to the major integrated oil companies and exempts from the tax the windfall profits invested back into searching for more energy or building refineries.
Rather than investing in more energy exploration, building more refineries, many big oil companies are currently buying back their stock, hoarding cash, or looking for more mergers and acquisitions on Wall Street – “drilling for oil” on Wall Street, as Business Week Magazine describes it. (I’ve got news for them – there’s no oil on Wall Street.)
The 50 percent windfall profits tax (on profits above $40 a barrel) I’m calling for will be the biggest incentive you can find for the big oil companies to invest in things that increase domestic energy supply, and thereby avoid paying the tax.
http://www.in-forum.com/articles/index.cfm?id=107686§ion=Opinion