The Illinois Dept of Revenue upheld our findings on Provena hospital here in Chamapign Urbana, and we denied them property tax exemptions. IN PART, this was because of the charity care program they claimed to have but sporadically followed. They were using extreme collections practices and were suing low income people who SHOULD have been given charity care and weren't.
Lucette Lagnado from the Wall Street Journal has done a couple articles on it, the first one hit the front page of the WSJ late in October, the last one was in Feb when the IDOR decision hit.
http://bernie.house.gov/documents/articles/20031031155424.asphttp://ahp.org/other/021904-WSJ-article.htmI'd say that the articles about the collections practices in the Wall Street Journal may have helped with the battle, but frankly, Illinois property tax code is quite specific on what hospitals should be doing--and many are not. Further, Sen Obama and Lt. Gov. Pat Quinn have been huge contributors in working to make it legislatively clear what Illinois expects from our health care providers. I have hopes that AG Lisa Madigan's office will continue this even further.
http://www.healthbusinessandpolicy.com/TAXChallenge.htmAbove is a link to a feature on the subject. I gave an interview to Jim Unland, the Editor of the Health Business Policy Journal (yes, I am on that page and you can see my picture and hear my voice.) He's an amazing guy--I felt like maybe he'd get the story right and see ALL the reasons why we ruled the way we did. He's taken the opportunity to educate hospitals and administrators on what they should be doing and how to better serve local communities.
I can't tell you how much it helps me to see that what we did IS having an impact in the state, and potentially, nationwide. This represents a year of my work and even tho that part is done, my involvement continues.
We CAN change this system even with the GOP controlled federal government. EVERYBODY needs to realize this and keep fighting.
Laura