Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

A Labor Day Tale Of Three Cities: Pittsburgh, Birmingham and New Orleans

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Editorials & Other Articles Donate to DU
 
Phil Rockstroh Donating Member (106 posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Mon Sep-05-11 08:28 PM
Original message
A Labor Day Tale Of Three Cities: Pittsburgh, Birmingham and New Orleans
Edited on Mon Sep-05-11 08:44 PM by Phil Rockstroh
Editor's Note: For several decades, America’s political/media elites have song the siren song of a post-industrial economy based on “free trade” and “financial innovations” – while silencing dissent that questioned this new-age group think. Now, the results are in, as Phil Rockstroh encountered in the cities of Pittsburgh, Birmingham and New Orleans.

A Labor Day Tale Of Three Cities: Pittsburgh, Birmingham and New Orleans
by Phil Rockstroh

http://consortiumnews.com/2011/09/05/a-labor-day-tale-of-three-cities/


As Hurricane Irene made her way up the Eastern Seaboard, my wife and I packed a few changes of clothes and trundled westward out of her path to spend the storm's duration in Pittsburgh, PA.

The excursion did us some good, in particular, leaving insular Manhattan, and facing the faded, crumbling Industrial Age grandeur of Pittsburgh. Walking, once again, among the plaintive rasps of the ghosts of the devastated laboring class (the social setting of our youth) provided us with a humanizing contrast to our present day circumstances stranded amid the manic chattering of the preening demons of banal self-regard possessing Manhattan careerists.

Nowadays, the island of Manhattan is tediously bright and shiny -- a sterile, oligarchic controlled dystopia. Accordingly, any sign of redemptive decay and hint of shabby ass human glory has been banished by official caveat and collective collusion.

In contrast, while in Pittsburgh, because I was born in a steel and coal town, Birmingham, Alabama, I shuffled among familiar shades. Deep in my being, I know the social setup -- once manifested in forged steel, living flesh and human longing -- now lost to the ravages of time (more accurately, the consequences of neo-liberal economic doctrine).

In Birmingham, under the statue of the Roman god of the forge, Vulcan, his mortared gaze lording over the city from atop Red Mountain, I witnessed men, hardened by years of grinding labor and demagogic political manipulation, sacrifice their bodies to (Pittsburgh plutocrat-owned) mines, foundries and smelting plants for subsistence pay.

In childhood, when I watched local men labor in the city's metal foundries, their sweat-lacquered faces, reflecting the fiery glow of smelted steel, seemed to glisten with rage, as angry blue sparks showered the heat-seared air around them.

These were hard-drinking, short-tempered men who were calloused of hand and possessed of humiliation-hardened hearts…rendered so, by a life of the strenuous labor, mandated by an exploitive economic system that bequeathed to them little but a hard scrabble existence--and the promise of a future bearing more of the same.

Little wonder, they swore into the soot-choked air, brawled among themselves, and clutched (self-defeating but politically useful to the ruling elite) racial animus, as their vitality was harnessed to build the structure and infrastructure of the industrial state and increase the wealth, privilege and political power of steel and coal plutocrats up in Pittsburgh (the absentee owners of the area's coal and iron mines, smelts, and processing plants) -- but, in so doing, we locals further diminished the steerage of the course of our lives.

I learned early the girding lie that sustains the oligarchic state i.e., the illusory promise: Work hard and you will set yourself free. In fact, as was the rigged economic setup of the Birmingham of my youth, the harder one works within the inverted totalitarian structure of the corporate state, the more one increases the wealth, hence the political power of the ruling elite…by enabling the parasitic class to consolidate yet more power. Therefore, by working harder and longer for their benefit, one further diminishes one's control over the trajectory of one's fate.

(Caveat: This is not to be confused with hard work and diligent effort -- a million acts of responsibility create freedom. The distinction being…be aware of who benefits from your efforts and mindfully choose where to apply your labors.)

At present, in cities such as Birmingham and Pittsburgh, the structures, built in the mechanized fury of the Industrial Age, stand idle…decaying around legions of the unemployed and the woefully underpaid and under-compensated. In the oxidized scream of rust, one can almost hear the wails of rage of those souls who surrendered their life force to erect and work the now abandoned factories, mills and foundries of the nation.

Outsourcing, downsizing, work speed-ups, i.e., the most recent mechanisms of capitalism's death cult of dehumanizing efficiency goes all but unchallenged in the official narrative of the corporate state. By means of intimidation and the proffering of small bribes, the work force is induced to transmute their body's vitality and soul's pothos into the profits of an advantaged, ruthless few. In this way, one's pothos (Greek: yearning plus libido) is rendered into the convenient pathos (alienation, paranoia, displaced rage, consumer addiction) of the corporate age.

Why do so many in the U.S. accept this pernicious, self-defeating setup? Perhaps, because they have been convinced by constant saturation by the commercial propaganda of the consumer state that capitalism will bestow to those who abide by its (rigged) rules and (gamed) economic arrangements everything one could possibly need and desire.

Accordingly, all an individual needs to know and experience is at his impulsive, electronic mass media-happy fingertips. He can click from virtual reality enactments of explicit porn to obscene interpretations of Christian prophecy (e.g., the present field of Republican presidential hopefuls) thus, in an instant, transmigrating from fake sin to phony salvation ... What more, in the whole of boundless creation, could one possibly want?

Yet, where does a veritable (as opposed to virtual) sense of place exist in social and economic arrangements such as these?

The present era of weightless perception serves to obscure the crushing consequences of the short-sighted cupidity of both the economic elite and underclasses alike. Reflecting this, wealth now exists as constellations of electrons; money is no longer the vaulted riches of miserly plutocrats nor payday cash of the laboring class burning in the pockets of worn work clothes.

Currency exists in precincts of pixels--a fever dream of appliances--the effluvia of the schemes of the elitist illusionists of high finance whose machinations have wrought an age of electronic razzle-dazzle and devastating real world consequences…whereby the solid architecture and durable accoutrement of the Machine Age, manifested as the sturdy structures of Industrial Era cities, such as Pittsburgh and Birmingham, has been transmuted into the manic, evanescent imagery of the mass media hologram.

In the years since Katrina, I've been known to rage at the indifferent sky, why the Hell (or, at least, its earthly exurb -- Houston) did nature's impersonal fury have to descend on New Orleans, about the last outposts within this corporate simulacrum of a country where an individual pulse and collective heart beat could be found -- where the primordial songs of bone, heart and flesh -- of the arias rising from steam-caressed sidewalks and the riffing currents of rivers -- have not been forced into the Clear Channel/Disney/Time-Warner überculture blandification machine?

In order for the U.S. -- a nation whose populace possesses the collective capacity for cognitive depth and emotional resonance of a Louisiana gnat flurry in high summer -- to rise from its destructive swoon of insularity-engendered anomie, the embrace of a view of the world imbued by anima mundi, embodied in the living architecture of a city like New Orleans, is essential.

In New Orleans, interred corpses will not remain buried in the earth…the water sodden ground causes the dead to rise to the surface. Axiomatically, we must not deep-six our grief and rage. In the name of Katrina's dead and walking wounded, we must not allow the casuistry-shattering verities of the human heart to be buried and forgotten nor allow mass media schlock to drown out the lamentations of the city's restless dead from memory.

To honor her dead, displaced and deeply scarred, we must remember the mortifying sights and heart-shaking sounds of both the natural disaster that was Katrina and the official shit storm of human negligence, flat-out deceit and malevolence that rendered the Crescent City a corpse-choked drowning pool. Instead, we must gaze down into the dark water of memory, remembering the water-deluged streets of the city…awash with bloated bodies, raw sewage, industrial sludge and the floating debris and submerge detritus of peoples' lives.

Yet, to properly mourn what was lost to the storm (in the tradition of the city itself) one must allow one's grieving heart to be seduced by the soul of the world. Personally, as is the case with many who knew the city, pre-Katrina -- beautiful, disloyal, capricious creature she was (and remains) — I retain a lover's ardor for her.

For: Being enveloped by the redolence of orange blossom and jasmine, held on her humid, late afternoon air, as I sat, swigging a Turbo Dog, on the banks of the Mississippi, as evening tilted over the Lower Ninth. For: The exquisite indifference of starlight above the Bywater, and the manner those distant, celestial bodies would stand in stark contrast to the redemptive immediacy of the sweat-soaked bodies near me, as we would lie on our backs, upon the sidewalk, watching steam (borne of the mass of humanity within) rise from the roof of Vaughan's Lounge…listening, as inside, Kermit Ruffins and the Barbecue Swingers wailed into the early morning hours.

I suspect my years in New Orleans saved/cursed me from being agenda-prone. I’m not of the reductionist school. I’m drawn to swamps…not so much the muck — but the mindfulness needed to negotiate the terrain. Of course, swamps will bog one down; yet, I’m drawn to the cacophony and filtered light, to its minute gradations of green upon green … One is forced to slow down in order to take in the revealed beauty and hidden dangers therein.

Moreover, the swamp exists for its own sake and feels no obligation to explain its mystery. It can be known, but its mystery is just that … ever growing, always dying.

One must not, and this is a habitual misstep of the contemporary left, approach politics, personality and place as a strictly intellectual exercise -- as a thought experiment that will yield to logic. If the swamp of the human psyche were that simple to negotiate, then life would be a dry, blood-bereft trudge indeed.

And yet, how the world wounds us; at times, delivering an aching sorrow that one will always carry. But rejoice in your wounded condition…for the open wound harbors a mouth to kiss…a womb from which to be perennially reborn. As Octavio Paz testifies, “Love is a wound, an injury…Yes, love is a flower of blood.”

As far as the struggle to be included in the present political narrative, we, on the left, remain marginalized to the point of near invisibility. But don't lose heart: The problem is the solution. Apropos, empire carries the seeds of its own demise. Therefore, in the shadow of the house of cards economy, now tottering over the ruins and detritus of the nation's shuttered factories, foreclosed upon farms, and abandoned mills, one should go about the business of working on what will replace the hollow and decayed system when it collapses from within.

Accordingly, Rainer Maria Rilke averred (paraphrasing) everyone has a letter written within and if you refuse the life your heart wants to live, you don’t get to read this letter before you die. An individual must risk the world, with all its attendant woundings, or he risks having a dead letter office piling up lost correspondence from his neglected heart.

Phil Rockstroh is a poet, lyricist and philosopher bard living in New York City. He may be contacted at:
phil@philrockstroh.com

. Visit Phil's website http://philrockstroh.com / And at FaceBook: http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100...
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
tooeyeten Donating Member (441 posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Mon Sep-05-11 10:38 PM
Response to Original message
1. it would help
if the facts were applied "the mortifying sights and heart-shaking sounds of both the natural disaster that was Katrina "

Katrina New Orleans six year ago was not a natural event it was a man-made event, memorialized in a documentary. and how a Federal agency was the source and cause of the destruction of the city. http://www.thebiguneasy.com/

Including the handling of New Orleans by the White House the week of August 29, 2005. http://www.salon.com/books/excerpt/2008/06/06/rove_katrina/print.html

Does this look lika a natural disaster?
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
distantearlywarning Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 08:27 AM
Response to Original message
2. Aspects of this are not quite accurate about Pittsburgh
Edited on Tue Sep-06-11 08:30 AM by distantearlywarning
For one thing, Pittsburgh currently has one of the best unemployment rates in the country. And although we do still have urban decay left over from the collapse of the steel mills in the 1980's, things have been gradually improving here year by year over the last decade. Individual people and organizations have been slowly but surely fixing stuff up, which has made many, many parts of this city extremely beautiful. And our main industries now are education and health care. In general, there is a vibe here of hopefulness that isn't necessarily present in other American cities right now - most of the 'burghers I personally know are positive about the future of Pittsburgh, quite happy, and in a surprising number of cases, shockingly well-off during this national recession, not bemoaning "the plaintive rasps of the ghosts of the devastated laboring class". A person could do a lot worse than Pittsburgh right now.

Also, steel mill work wasn't necessarily always "subsistence pay". One of the reasons why the collapse of the steel mills in the 1980's did such a number on the city is because men who worked in the mills could no longer support their families on pay in the non-mill world. A steel mill job, while dirty and dangerous and hard, often paid enough here to buy a house and raise children. This wasn't true of other non-white collar jobs outside the mills.

Also, although it is true that Pittsburgh's industrialists both used the workers of the city for profit and did bad things to the environment here, some good also came from that time in our history. One thing that people don't realize about Pittsburgh's captains of industry is how charitable and socially minded they were in comparison to their modern equivalents. In particular, Pittsburgh's industrialists, unlike those in other cities of the age, were devoted to improving the lives and minds of the populace of the city who worked in their mills, and funneled a not insignificant portion of their profits into cultural infrastructure here, including hundreds of examples of gorgeous architecture, museums, free and public educational institutions (e.g., every neighborhood in Pittsburgh has a functional public "Carnegie Library"), cultural endowments and trusts, etc., that were built specifically for the use of the mill workers and their descendants. 100 years later, this legacy is now the primary reason why Pittsburgh is sometimes called "The Paris of Appalachia", and why Pittsburgh is quickly moving out of its rust belt past into the modern age.

Also, it isn't really accurate to say that the industrialists of Pittsburgh were absentee landlords. Many of the bigger names lived here inside the city and suffered the soot just as their workers did. Their houses are still here today, some of which have become museums and others living spaces for the modern middle class. If you read their biographies, it's clear that they were committed to the city in a fundamental way, not *just* using her people for profit.


I am not saying any of this to excuse the evil that they did here (because it was substantial). I'm just saying that that part isn't the full story. And it didn't break Pittsburgh - it made her what she is today, which is something interesting and cool and on an upward trajectory, not wallowing in the past.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
ladywnch Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 10:08 AM
Response to Reply #2
3. and having real leadership (Dick Caligeri) during the fall of steel
and the rise of technologies in the area. Pittsburgh could have gone the way of Detroit but it didn't. His Renaissance II programs saved the city and made it "The Most Livable City in America" several years in a row.

Where is a Dick Caligeri (sp?) when the country needs them?





apologies if I spelled his name wrong.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
bread_and_roses Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 11:27 AM
Response to Reply #2
4. Fuck their philanthropy. And as for how cool Pittsburgh is today -
Fuck their philanthropy. Fuck their charity. Fuck their fake benevolence. Every cent was stolen from workers - it's blood-soaked money.

And as for how cool Pittsburgh is today - take a trip on the Ohio and see the former Mill Towns (I grew up in one of them, about 20 mi from "the city"). The death of the working class amid the rise of the Vampire insurance and profiteering health "care" industries ain't so pretty.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
KamaAina Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 11:57 AM
Response to Original message
5. Some of the best writing about NOLA I've read in a while
and that's saying something. :thumbsup:

You might enjoy this:

http://toulousestreet.wordpress.com
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
Overseas Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 12:04 PM
Response to Original message
6. K&R.
Thank you for another beautiful essay.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
squirrelhillgrofys Donating Member (1 posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 02:50 PM
Response to Original message
7. very good script, albeit...
the info about pittsburgh is inaccurate. whatever it was during the mill days(and i can say nothing positive about carnegie any other mill owner, especially after pinkerton guards were hired to kill strikers during the homestead steel strike of 1892, among other incidents) pittsburgh it quite a different city now. the city repeatedly has made the "most livable" list and is becoming a mecca for tech start-ups. in a 5-6 mile radius there are at least 6 colleges/universities that attract students from all over the world. upmc medical center ranked as one of the best in the country and we are very politically active. of course it is in no wise perfect, but we are not the city that "built in the mechanized fury of the Industrial Age, stand idle…decaying around legions of the unemployed and the woefully underpaid and under-compensated". that world is gone.

as well, i don't know anyone since the 70's who can relate to this: "In the oxidized scream of rust, one can almost hear the wails of rage of those souls who surrendered their life force to erect and work the now abandoned factories, mills and foundries of the nation". you write very well, but you should have stayed longer to get an accurate view of the city.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
tooeyeten Donating Member (441 posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Tue Sep-06-11 11:41 PM
Response to Reply #7
8. neither
was the information on New Orleans.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
DU AdBot (1000+ posts) Click to send private message to this author Click to view 
this author's profile Click to add 
this author to your buddy list Click to add 
this author to your Ignore list Mon Apr 15th 2024, 11:48 PM
Response to Original message
Advertisements [?]
 Top

Home » Discuss » Editorials & Other Articles Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC