Mistakes in Typography Grate the Purists

[Renew Deal]

Dirt. Noise. Crowds. Delays. Scary smells. Even scarier fluids swirling on the floor. There are lots of reasons to loathe the New York City subway, but one very good reason to love it — Helvetica, the typeface that’s used on its signage.

Seeing the clean, crisp shapes of those letters and numbers at station entrances, on the platforms and inside the trains is always a treat, at least it is until I spot the “Do not lean ...” sign on the train doors. Ugh! There’s something not quite right about the “e” and the “a” in the word “lean.” Somehow they seem too small and too cramped. Once I’ve noticed them, the memory of the clean, crisp letters fades, and all I remember are the “off” ones.

That’s the problem with loving typography. It’s always a pleasure to discover a formally gorgeous, subtly expressive typeface while walking along a street or leafing through a magazine. (Among my current favorites are the very elegant letters in the new identity of the Paris fashion house, Céline, and the jolly jumble of multi-colored fonts on the back of the Rossi Ice Cream vans purring around London.) But that joy is swiftly obliterated by the sight of a typographic howler. It’s like having a heightened sense of smell. You spend much more of your time wincing at noxious stinks, than reveling in delightful aromas.

If it’s bad for me (an amateur enthusiast who is interested in typography, but isn’t hugely knowledgeable about it), what must it be like for the purists? Dreadful, it seems. I feel guilty enough about grumbling to my friends whenever I see this or that typographic gaffe, but am too ignorant to spot all of them, unlike the designers who work with typefaces on a daily basis, and study them lovingly.
<snip>

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/16/arts/16iht-design16.html

[NV Whino]

1. I fired a client who kept wanting me to alter a typeface dor his logo.

He couldn't understand why I kept refusing to do it. Finally I said, enough, and told him to find someone else to do it.

[MineralMan]

2. It's good that some people care about such things.

I don't share that particular fetish, but that kind of attention makes for a more pleasant world, even if we don't know why.

[muriel_volestrangler]

3. Meh - *real* subway systems don't just use a typeface, they commission one

and then get it spread across the world:

http://www.identifont.com/show?1YL