The two visions of the future, centrist versus ultraconservative, are being played out in the Republican party. They reflect larger societal trends where a plurality of Americans consider themselves conservative. Conservative Democrats and moderate Republicans comprise the swing block in congress. This bloc threatens to derail Obama's grand vision of a more egalitarian society.
Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's centrism in California appeals less to the Republican Party base than the resistance push of Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky.
By JOHN HARWOOD
Published: July 27, 2009
...Mr. Schwarzenegger ...His blend of fiscal conservatism and social moderation produced two lopsided election victories in the blue-state colossus of California...Yet that formulation has proved more successful in campaigns than governance.
Mr. Schwarzenegger has appealed directly to Californians - most recently in springtime ballot initiatives designed to attack the deficit by capping spending and raising taxes. Voters shouted "No!" - forcing last week's deal to cut spending on state services so deeply that even the governor declined to declare victory.
The results have estranged him from both sides, producing Bush-like approval ratings of under 40 percent.
Inside the Capitol, Mr. McConnell has a different Republican message: stick together in resisting Mr. Obama's ambition.
He continued, "And the assumption that doing health care is going to help the economy, which the president's been selling, is utter nonsense." That message gains traction with every new caution from the Congressional Budget Office, every tick up in unemployment, every slip in Mr. Obama's approval ratings.
Competing Brands of Republicanism