The Myth of the Moral Majority

[Joanne98]

Books: Here's the church. Here's the steeple. Open the doors and—hey, where did all the evangelicals go?


this february, the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life released the most comprehensive of its surveys of the "religious landscape" of the United States. Front and center was the finding that 26 percent of American adults—around 54 million—are evangelical Protestants. The idea that 1 in every 4 of us thumps a Bible only confirmed what many had assumed to be gospel since 2000, when evangelical voters were credited with winning the White House for George W. Bush and the media began its grand genuflections toward a resurgent fundamentalism, casting evangelicals (and more broadly, "values voters") as a politicized wedge that politicians ignored at their peril.

And who could blame them? Not only are evangelicals supposedly our biggest religious voting bloc, but Pew reports that nearly 80 percent of Americans are Christian, and 40 percent attend church weekly according to Gallup Polls. But what if those numbers—and everything we've assumed they tell us about the power of the religious right—are wildly wrong?

Take that 40 percent church attendance stat. Looking around her half-empty Southern Baptist church outside Dallas, Christine Wicker had her doubts. Wicker, a veteran Texas newspaper reporter, was born again when she was nine but drifted away from her evangelical roots in adulthood. A few years ago, she returned to the Southern Baptist Church to both renew her faith and write The Fall of the Evangelical Nation, an insider's look at evangelicals' power, wading in where secular journalists feared to tread. When she started looking into the numbers on church attendance, she found that researchers could vouch for only 18 percent of Americans being regular churchgoers—less than half the accepted figure. That led her to wonder about the already widely reported claim that 25 percent of Americans are evangelicals; could the real number also be less than half that?

In size, only the Catholic Church dwarfs the Southern Baptist Church, the biggest evangelical denomination and by far the most organized and fastidious of the Protestant record keepers. But Wicker discovered that the numbers the Southern Baptist Convention (sbc) releases for public consumption tell a much different story than the ones it uses internally. The organization claims 16 million members, but as one reverend cracks, "the fbi couldn't find half of if they had to." A 2006 sbc report states that only 11 million of its members live in the same area as their home church anymore; that number includes those who've been double- or even triple-counted elsewhere. It also includes perennial no-shows and those who attend services at "bedside Baptist" (they sleep in on Sunday but show up for Easter and Christmas). And that's not to mention those who've lost their religion or converted to another faith. If their names were ever on "the roll" at a Baptist church, they're probably inscribed there for life.

With more digging, Wicker came across a 2007 sbc report that found only 5.4 million adults attended services regularly enough to be considered church members. Further complicating matters, many of those who regularly filled the pews weren't official members, and, most significantly, 1 in 8 wasn't saved or born again. Factoring all this in, Wicker calculated that there are fewer than 4 million devoted Southern Baptists. Her math seems to be backed up by collection-plate totals: If the church truly has 16 million members, then they contributed a miserly $3.50 each to a nationwide fundraising campaign last year.

And it's not just the Southern Baptists who appear to be playing number games. The National Association of Evangelicals, an umbrella group that does not include the sbc, claimed 30 million members on its website. When Wicker contacted the association for comment, the figure changed to 4.5 million. No one there could—or would—explain the sudden 85 percent drop in believers. (However, the group's website currently describes its lobbying arm as the voice of "30 million Americans united under a common banner.")

The emperor's-new-clothes flimsiness of these widely accepted exaggerated numbers says much about the cold calculation of far-right religious leaders. Moral Majority and Focus on the Family have happily staked their clout on coreligionists who never knew they were being counted—often twice or three times—among the faithful for political ends. "The idea that evangelicals are taking over America is one of the greatest publicity scams in history," Wicker concludes, "a perfect coup accomplished by savvy politicos and religious leaders, who understand media weaknesses and exploit them brilliantly."

Though she doesn't delve into those weaknesses, Wicker's findings speak volumes about the limitations of a Fourth Estate that accepted and uncritically deferred to the power of the religious right. Having been handed a ready-made story line by the thou-shalt-not brigades, the media became transfixed by a phenomenon they couldn't fully fathom but felt bound to report on. Those unexamined numbers and claims of followers in theological lockstep launched a thousand cover stories and columns—rarely prompting questions about what a term as broad as "evangelical" really meant on the ground. Whether they viewed it as a new political reality, a megatrend, or a bogeyman, the media embraced the idea of a reenergized, monolithic Christianity and faithfully chronicled something that didn't exist.
http://www.motherjones.com/arts/feature/2008/05/the-myth-of-the-moral-majority.html

[grannylib]

1. I believe Kucinich touched on this issue, at least in a way, when

he talked about the polls where the questions have been neutral, showing that a pretty substantial majority, if I remember right, of those polled were pretty damn progressive on a whole host of issues; it's just that the Reich Wing has been pretty damn good on its own at framing the debate and manipulating/being in cahoots with the M$M

[chill_wind]

2. The "Moral Majority" is Neither.

But they have a lot of money and influence, and they never, never give up or go away.

[Warpy]

3. There was a "snapshot" that came out a few years ago

that came to the same conclusion as to the paltry number of committed churchgoers.

Since then, the whole thing has broken down even farther because 6 years with "their" people controlling all three branches of the government didn't advance any of their social agenda except ending a safe, second trimester abortion procedure and endangering the lives of women who need later abortions for medical reasons. Abortion is not only still legal, they are fighting a losing battle to keep homosexual Americans from access to the body of civil law governing marriage.

To say this small but noisy and reliable voting bloc feels betrayed is a gross understatement.

In addition, they've lost the youth completely as the youth are facing huge student loans with only low paying jobs left in much of this country and no sign of a way out. Somehow pushing women back into reproductive slavery and gay men back into the closet doesn't seem quite as important when you're trying to figure out how to pay that loan payment and rent while filling up the car to get to work that doesn't pay enough to live on.

Of all the people who have been betrayed by this gang of thieves and butchers, the evangelicals, whether or not they actually go to church or even own a bible, justifiably feel the most betrayed.

My best guess is that they will once again become apolitical members of the lunatic fringe, something they seemed perfectly happy with before Reagan handed the party platform to them.