What Is the Latest Thing to Be Discouraged About? The Rise of Pessimism

[WePurrsevere]

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/28/opinion/28mon4.html?th&emc=th

The early stages of the Iraq war may have been a watershed in American optimism. The happy talk was so extreme it is now difficult to believe it was sincere: “we will be greeted as liberators”; “mission accomplished”; the insurgency is “in the last throes.” Most wildly optimistic of all was the goal: a military action transforming the Middle East into pro-American democracies.

The gap between predictions and reality has left Americans deeply discouraged. So has much of what has happened, or not happened, at the same time. Those who believed New Orleans would rebound quickly after Hurricane Katrina have seen their hopes dashed. Those counting on solutions to health care, energy dependence or global warming have seen no progress. It is no wonder the nation is in a gloomy mood; 71 percent of respondents in a recent Associated Press-Ipsos poll said the country is on the wrong track.

These are ideal times for the release of “Pessimism: Philosophy, Ethic, Spirit,” by Joshua Foa Dienstag, a U.C.L.A. political theorist. Mr. Dienstag aims to rescue pessimism from the philosophical sidelines, where it has been shunted by optimists of all ideologies. The book is seductive, because pessimists are generally more engaging and entertaining than optimists, and because, as the author notes, “the world keeps delivering bad news.” It is almost tempting to throw up one’s hands and sign on with Schopenhauer.

<snip>
Part of Mr. Bush’s legacy may well be that he robbed America of its optimism — a force that Franklin Delano Roosevelt and other presidents, like Ronald Reagan, used to rally the country when it was deeply challenged. The next generation of leaders will have to resell discouraged Americans on the very idea of optimism, and convince them again that their goal should not be to live with their ailments, but to cure them.

[Demeter]

1. Pessimism Is a Good and ENCOURAGING Thing!

It means dissatisfaction, which means change, which means doing something diferent, which is what we've been screaming, crying and praying for lo these 6 years.

[WePurrsevere]

3. Pessimism can be a good thing IF it leads to action & not depression which

sadly tends to immobilize us. If it leads to anger and action then I'm for it... anger and holding TIGHT onto HOPE it what keeps me going and fighting. If I didn't believe we could change things I would have given up long ago.. and on many things.

[Paranoid Pessimist]

2. In my considerable experience, the best thing about pessimism

is that oftentimes things don't go down as badly as I thought they would. Pessimists are often relieved whereas optimists get disappointed. Of course, the way things are going, there are plenty of grounds for pessimism. Things are going to hell in a handbasket, all trendlines are heading toward worsening, and all hell shows signs of being about ready to break loose.

As always, I hope I'm wrong.

[WePurrsevere]

4. Sometimes change is horrible & scary when we are going through it

but change needs to happen for growth and I believe things will be better in the long run... we just have to hold on to hope and keep fighting for what we know in our hearts is right.

"This too shall pass"... as all things eventually do.