Durbin's message/U.S. must end prisoner abuse

[moobu2]

"Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., set off a firestorm last week when he compared U.S. treatment of prisoners at Guantanamo to practices employed by Nazis, Soviets, Pol Pot and their ilk. His remarks were condemned by the White House, the Pentagon, the Christian Coalition, the Veterans of Foreign Wars, Newt Gingrich (who called for his censure by the Senate) and by the entire right side of the talk radio/television/blog world. The heat got so bad that, late in the week, Durbin apologized if his remarks had been "misunderstood." They weren't, and Durbin should not have apologized.

Instead, the senator should have hit back hard, just as the Amnesty International did when its comparison of Guantanamo to the Soviet gulag was attacked. By caving in, Durbin did just what the orchestrated right-wing smear effort required to succeed: It made him the story rather than focusing further attention on the outrageous violations of international law and human rights being perpetrated in Guantanamo and elsewhere in the name of the American people.

The comments that were criticized came late in a long, thoughtful speech on the Senate floor in which Durbin reflected on the United States' obligation to be better than reprehensible regimes of the past. He talked at some length about mistakes American presidents made in previous wars (repealing habeas corpus during the Civil War, interning Americans of Japanese descent during World War II, taking over the steel industry during the Korean War), and he urged President Bush to recognize and rectify his mistake in prisoner treatment during the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Durbin's entire speech is too long to reprint, but lengthy excerpts can be found on the page opposite.

Durbin was spot on in his assessment of Guantanamo. That's why he was so roundly attacked. He told the truth. And his message is of vital importance; the United States is better than this."

Star Tribune

Username-Demomaniac
Password-Demomaniac

[GettysbergII]

1. Kudos to the Star-Tribune!

[omega minimo]

2. Why'd he cave?

:shrug:

[GettysbergII]

3. First, Richard J Daley aka Mayor Bush sandbagged him

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=150x8102

This is one of the most unwarranted and reprehensible actions of a mayor who created new standards in unwarranted and reprehensible behavior.

However he might also be in part taking one on the chin for the Gipper. A major report done by the DNC on voting irregularities in 2004is coming out today and I'm sure the DNC doesn't want to give the MSM the Durbin story to rehash over and over and ignore this important and substancial report\ as is the MSM want when Karl orders them to 'bend over and roll up your sleeves'. With Durbin apologizing it ceases to be newsworthy.

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=show_mesg&forum=203&topic_id=379657&mesg_id=379657

[omega minimo]

4. Aaaaaaaaahhhh. Strategery.

:puke: