HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Retired » Retired Forums » 2016 Postmortem (Forum) » And the 2016 Ralph Nader ...

Wed Jan 18, 2017, 02:27 AM

 

And the 2016 Ralph Nader Award Goes to Bernie Sanders - Time.com [View all]

Sanders distracted Hillary Clinton from creating a unified vision for the future

On Election Day, Senator Bernie Sanders earned the 2016 “Ralph Nader Award” for the Leftist Most Responsible for Helping Republicans Win the Presidency. True, Donald Trump cleverly exploited voters’ frustrations. And Hillary Clinton’s campaign in 2016 was as rigid and empty as it was when she lost in 2008. Still, Sanders helped Clinton lose. His insurgency pushed her too far left to prevent an effective re-centering in the fall, while goading her into wooing different constituencies rather than uniting the nation.

In fairness, Sanders ran a surprisingly effective campaign tapping the same anti-establishment fury Donald Trump stirred. Although Sanders and Trump are very different, their campaigns were not. Each treated Hillary Clinton as a compromised, Wall Street–worshipping, Establishment sellout. Both demonized Washington insiders and free trade, rather than tackling the real structural problem: the United States deindustrialized because Americans refuse to pay what it costs to hire American workers and instead buy cheaper imported products. As a result, just as Ralph Nader siphoned tens of thousands of votes on Election Day 2000 in Florida from Al Gore, causing the deadlock and George W. Bush’s victory, Bernie Sanders’ similar vampire effect enfeebled Hillary Clinton.

This dynamic followed a classic historical pattern. Sanders drew Clinton from the center toward the Democrats’ extreme flank. That shift paralleled Jimmy Carter’s leftward lurch when Ted Kennedy ran in 1980, and George H.W. Bush’s rightwing swerve when Pat Buchanan rebelled in 1992. Each time, the frontrunners felt forced to placate loyalists they should have been able to take for granted, while embracing extreme positions that haunted them during the general election campaign.

This year replayed that Insurgent’s Vampire Effect. Clinton expected to inherit the nomination without serious opponents. Joe Biden and John Kerry, each of whom sees a potential president whenever he looks in the mirror, didn’t run, deferring to the Clintons’ power in the party and to Hillary Clinton’s claim that it was “our time” as women to win the presidency—an appeal that, surprisingly, bored younger women.

As an independent, Sanders lacked such loyalty. His hip campaign addressed the displaced and disempowered, claiming Hillary Clinton was the problem not the solution. In response, Hillary Clinton channeled Walter Mondale in 1984, desperately appealing to different special interests. Characteristically, after winning Super Tuesday, she declared: “We have to defend all our rights—workers’ rights, and women’s rights, civil rights and voting rights, LGBT rights and rights for people with disabilities.” This pluralistic appeal failed to offer a unifying national mission. It illustrated Donald Trump’s complaint that Democrats were so busy kowtowing to minorities they neglected the white majority and the nation’s need for consensus.

Having catered to the millennial and minority sensibility in the spring, Hillary Clinton missed the mainstream, failing to recalibrate for the fall. This misread was most apparent in her neglect of her greatest political ally, Bill Clinton, and his legacy. In the 1990s, President Clinton shrewdly led from the center, forging a “Third Way” progressivism more balanced than the big-government, special interest group-oriented liberalism which Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush handily defeated in the 1980s. Clintonite centrism embraced free trade as bringing prosperity not exporting jobs. Clinton fought crime, framing it as threat to all Americans, especially blacks. Clinton reformed welfare to restore governmental credibility and recipients’ dignity. Clinton talked candidly about restructuring the economy while rebuilding traditional culture, because too many Americans felt they were “living in the funhouse.”

Pressed by the Sanders Sensation, intimidated by Black Lives Matter, even Bill Clinton backpedaled, apologizing for fighting crime and his centrist legacy. With no one explaining how bad crime was in the 1990s, how dysfunctional the welfare system was, how two-thirds of blacks supported both initiatives, Clinton’s legislation seemed draconian. Hillary Clinton became a doughnut candidate, sprinkling sweets to particular groups but lacking any core. That distortion made her the perfect foil for Donald Trump’s demagoguery.

Sanders liberals considered Clintonian centrism not liberal enough, not minority-sensitive enough, not pure enough. The result is a president-elect hostile to liberalism, unafraid of demonizing minorities and epitomizing a killer instinct that makes Clintonian triangulation look naïve. All this makes Bernie Sanders the Ralph Nader of 2016


http://time.com/4569766/bernie-sanders-ralph-nader-2016/

180 replies, 27888 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 180 replies Author Time Post
Reply And the 2016 Ralph Nader Award Goes to Bernie Sanders - Time.com [View all]
factfinder_77 Jan 2017 OP
HassleCat Jan 2017 #1
Jake Stern Jan 2017 #8
Gothmog Jan 2017 #46
karynnj Jan 2017 #62
Gothmog Jan 2017 #101
karynnj Jan 2017 #103
Gothmog Jan 2017 #106
karynnj Jan 2017 #108
Gothmog Jan 2017 #111
WhiteTara Jan 2017 #63
Bill USA Jan 2017 #170
pangaia Jan 2017 #2
bettyellen Jan 2017 #3
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #6
bettyellen Jan 2017 #9
betsuni Jan 2017 #10
Wounded Bear Jan 2017 #11
Post removed Jan 2017 #13
Name removed Jan 2017 #57
Gothmog Jan 2017 #59
bettyellen Jan 2017 #20
Eliot Rosewater Jan 2017 #152
trueblue2007 Jan 2017 #25
Gothmog Jan 2017 #48
ThirdEye Jan 2017 #85
dionysus Jan 2017 #89
Arazi Jan 2017 #91
Gothmog Jan 2017 #98
brush Jan 2017 #56
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #72
R B Garr Jan 2017 #116
JudyM Jan 2017 #137
Alice11111 Jan 2017 #126
thesquanderer Jan 2017 #180
boston bean Jan 2017 #39
Name removed Jan 2017 #54
bravenak Jan 2017 #4
Gothmog Jan 2017 #47
bravenak Jan 2017 #80
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #94
JHan Jan 2017 #95
bravenak Jan 2017 #114
Gothmog Jan 2017 #147
CentralMass Jan 2017 #5
factfinder_77 Jan 2017 #14
CentralMass Jan 2017 #37
Duppers Jan 2017 #18
Post removed Jan 2017 #7
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #12
Duppers Jan 2017 #17
Locrian Jan 2017 #31
treestar Jan 2017 #69
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #83
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #84
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #141
Gothmog Jan 2017 #150
MelissaB Jan 2017 #110
riderinthestorm Jan 2017 #136
Rex Jan 2017 #140
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #15
world wide wally Jan 2017 #16
JCanete Jan 2017 #19
boston bean Jan 2017 #41
Gothmog Jan 2017 #50
JCanete Jan 2017 #97
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #128
boston bean Jan 2017 #130
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #133
boston bean Jan 2017 #134
JCanete Jan 2017 #173
Gothmog Jan 2017 #148
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #71
JCanete Jan 2017 #102
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #107
JCanete Jan 2017 #109
LanternWaste Jan 2017 #117
JCanete Jan 2017 #120
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #155
JCanete Jan 2017 #165
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #166
JCanete Jan 2017 #167
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #168
JCanete Jan 2017 #171
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #175
JCanete Jan 2017 #177
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #135
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #153
Ken Burch Jan 2017 #158
chwaliszewski Jan 2017 #21
JHB Jan 2017 #26
chwaliszewski Jan 2017 #30
JHB Jan 2017 #38
Gothmog Jan 2017 #149
Cha Jan 2017 #22
jg10003 Jan 2017 #23
WhiteTara Jan 2017 #65
ThirdEye Jan 2017 #86
treestar Jan 2017 #68
emulatorloo Jan 2017 #129
SticksnStones Jan 2017 #24
JudyM Jan 2017 #138
Post removed Jan 2017 #27
delisen Jan 2017 #32
Cooley Hurd Jan 2017 #35
delisen Jan 2017 #43
otohara Jan 2017 #53
WhiteTara Jan 2017 #66
JTFrog Jan 2017 #33
Lil Missy Jan 2017 #28
Tortmaster Jan 2017 #29
JHB Jan 2017 #40
JTFrog Jan 2017 #34
PotatoChip Jan 2017 #36
Gothmog Jan 2017 #60
dionysus Jan 2017 #90
Gothmog Jan 2017 #96
kenfrequed Jan 2017 #115
Gothmog Jan 2017 #123
kenfrequed Jan 2017 #156
Gothmog Jan 2017 #160
kenfrequed Jan 2017 #161
Gothmog Jan 2017 #162
Gothmog Jan 2017 #125
kenfrequed Jan 2017 #157
Gothmog Jan 2017 #159
kenfrequed Jan 2017 #163
kenfrequed Jan 2017 #164
dionysus Jan 2017 #118
Gothmog Jan 2017 #122
dionysus Jan 2017 #131
Gothmog Jan 2017 #145
Gothmog Jan 2017 #143
Cha Jan 2017 #142
Gothmog Jan 2017 #146
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #169
Paladin Jan 2017 #42
forjusticethunders Jan 2017 #44
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #74
Gothmog Jan 2017 #45
NWCorona Jan 2017 #49
Gothmog Jan 2017 #61
NWCorona Jan 2017 #64
Gothmog Jan 2017 #99
NWCorona Jan 2017 #105
Gothmog Jan 2017 #113
NWCorona Jan 2017 #119
Gothmog Jan 2017 #121
NWCorona Jan 2017 #132
Gothmog Jan 2017 #144
Haveadream Jan 2017 #51
R B Garr Jan 2017 #52
NCTraveler Jan 2017 #55
m-lekktor Jan 2017 #58
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #70
Raster Jan 2017 #79
treestar Jan 2017 #67
killbotfactory Jan 2017 #73
Raster Jan 2017 #100
Orsino Jan 2017 #75
guillaumeb Jan 2017 #76
BainsBane Jan 2017 #77
Raster Jan 2017 #78
Z_California Jan 2017 #81
tonedevil Jan 2017 #82
dionysus Jan 2017 #87
yallerdawg Jan 2017 #88
Vinca Jan 2017 #92
Arazi Jan 2017 #93
JHan Jan 2017 #127
Post removed Jan 2017 #104
JustinL Jan 2017 #112
flvegan Jan 2017 #124
Rex Jan 2017 #139
montanacowboy Jan 2017 #151
tecelote Jan 2017 #154
StevieM Jan 2017 #172
vaberella Jan 2017 #174
customerserviceguy Jan 2017 #176
AgadorSparticus Jan 2017 #178
thesquanderer Jan 2017 #179