HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Retired » Retired Forums » 2016 Postmortem (Forum) » The Root: Pipe Down, Bern... » Reply #98
In the discussion thread: The Root: Pipe Down, Bernie Sanders [View all]

Response to tecelote (Reply #28)

Sun Jan 15, 2017, 02:23 PM

98. Sanders was on the ballot in 2016 and under performed Clinton

Your theory is undercut by the fact that Sanders was on the ballot in 2016 and Sanders underperformed Hillary Clinton https://extranewsfeed.com/bernie-sanders-was-on-the-2016-ballot-and-he-underperformed-hillary-clinton-3b561e8cb779#.jbtsa3epl

Of course, this narrative ignores the facts ó that despite Clintonís supposed flaws, she easily defeated Sanders in the primary via the pledged delegate count, that Sanders inability to convince minority voters doomed his campaign for the nomination, and that the attempt to use superdelegates to override the popular vote was an undemocratic power grab.

And the white workers whose supposed ďhate for corporate interestsĒ led them to vote for Trump? They donít seem upset that Trump has installed three Goldman Sachs executives in his administration. They donít seem to be angry that Trumpís cabinet is the wealthiest in US history. And we havenít heard any discontent from the white working class over Trump choosing an Exxon Mobil CEO for Secretary of State.

The devil is in the details, and at first glance, it is easy to see why so many people can believe that Bernie actually would have won. He got a great deal of positive media coverage as the underdog early on, especially with Republicans deliberately eschewing attacks on him in favor of attacks on Clinton. His supporters also trended younger and whiter, demographics that tend to be more visible in the media around election time. A highly energized and vocal minority of Sanders supporters dominated social media, helping him win online polls by huge margins.

But at some point, you have to put away the narrative and actually evaluate performance. This happens in sports all the time, especially with hyped up amateur college prospects before they go pro. Big time college players are often surrounded by an aura, a narrative of sorts, which pushes many casual observers to believe their college skills will translate to success on the next level. But professional teams have to evaluate the performance of these amateur players to determine if they can have success as professionals, regardless what the narrative surrounding them in college was. A college player with a lot of hype isnít necessarily going to succeed professionally. In fact, some of the most hyped up prospects have the most underwhelming performances at the next level. In the same vein, we can evaluate Sandersí performance in 2016 and determine whether his platform is ready for the next level. Sanders endorsed a plethora of candidates and initiatives across the country, in coastal states and Rust Belt states. He campaigned for these candidates and initiatives because they represented his platform and his vision for the future of the Democratic Party. In essence, Bernie Sanders was on the 2016 ballot. Letís take a look at how he performed.

After looking at a number of races where sanders supported candidates under perform Hillary Clinton, that author makes a strong closing
If Sanders is so clearly the future of the Democratic Party, then why is his platform not resonating in diverse blue states like California and Colorado, where the Democratic base resides? Why are his candidates losing in the Rust Belt, where displaced white factory workers are supposed to be sympathetic to his message on trade? The key implication Sanders backers usually point to is that his agenda is supposed to not only energize the Democratic base, but bring over the white working class, which largely skews Republican. Universal healthcare, free college, a national $15 minimum wage, and government controlled prescription drug costs are supposed to be the policies that bring back a white working class that has gone conservative since Democrats passed Civil Rights. Sanders spent $40 million a month during the primary, and was largely visible during the general, pushing his candidates and his agenda across the country. The results were not good ó specifically in regards to the white working class. The white working class did not turnout for Feingold in Wisconsin, or for universal healthcare in Colorado. Instead, they voted against Bernieís platform, and voted for regular big business Republicans.

Why did Sanders underperform Clinton significantly throughout 2016 ó first in the primaries, and then with his candidates and initiatives in the general? If Sandersí platform and candidates had lost, but performed better than Clinton, than that would be an indicator that perhaps he was on to something. If they had actually won, then he could really claim to have momentum. But instead, we saw the opposite result: Sandersí platform lost, and lost by much bigger margins than Clinton did. It even lost in states Clinton won big. What does that tell us about the future of the Democratic Party? Well, perhaps we need to acknowledge that the Bernie Sanders platform just isnít as popular as itís made out to be.

If your theory on the importance of independents was correct, then Sanders should have out performed Clinton and not under performed

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 288 replies Author Time Post
bravenak Jan 2017 OP
tecelote Jan 2017 #1
bravenak Jan 2017 #3
tecelote Jan 2017 #4
bravenak Jan 2017 #11
LisaM Jan 2017 #16
bravenak Jan 2017 #29
LisaM Jan 2017 #36
radical noodle Jan 2017 #58
BlueCaliDem Jan 2017 #102
brush Jan 2017 #152
JTFrog Jan 2017 #92
redstatebluegirl Jan 2017 #242
bravenak Jan 2017 #243
liquid diamond Jan 2017 #84
womanofthehills Jan 2017 #281
otohara Jan 2017 #86
lunamagica Jan 2017 #105
MrPurple Jan 2017 #106
jonno99 Jan 2017 #275
KPN Jan 2017 #204
R B Garr Jan 2017 #278
tecelote Jan 2017 #17
bravenak Jan 2017 #24
tecelote Jan 2017 #32
bravenak Jan 2017 #34
tecelote Jan 2017 #35
George II Jan 2017 #66
Eliot Rosewater Jan 2017 #76
Gothmog Jan 2017 #101
bravenak Jan 2017 #173
George II Jan 2017 #175
sheshe2 Jan 2017 #177
mcar Jan 2017 #225
sheshe2 Jan 2017 #228
mcar Jan 2017 #229
KPN Jan 2017 #206
George II Jan 2017 #212
KPN Jan 2017 #216
George II Jan 2017 #218
KPN Jan 2017 #219
George II Jan 2017 #226
Gothmog Jan 2017 #236
Gothmog Jan 2017 #235
Exilednight Jan 2017 #199
KPN Jan 2017 #207
aikoaiko Jan 2017 #73
bravenak Jan 2017 #163
WhiteTara Jan 2017 #85
MadCrow Jan 2017 #143
WhiteTara Jan 2017 #151
k8conant Jan 2017 #182
sheshe2 Jan 2017 #183
KPN Jan 2017 #213
bravenak Jan 2017 #247
LenaBaby61 Jan 2017 #187
KPN Jan 2017 #208
WhiteTara Jan 2017 #210
NWCorona Jan 2017 #88
bravenak Jan 2017 #156
NWCorona Jan 2017 #157
Cha Jan 2017 #142
Gothmog Jan 2017 #93
sheshe2 Jan 2017 #158
bravenak Jan 2017 #174
sheshe2 Jan 2017 #178
LanternWaste Jan 2017 #223
kacekwl Jan 2017 #8
bravenak Jan 2017 #12
KPN Jan 2017 #211
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #20
bravenak Jan 2017 #26
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #39
Eliot Rosewater Jan 2017 #81
krawhitham Jan 2017 #68
bettyellen Jan 2017 #145
KPN Jan 2017 #209
secondwind Jan 2017 #126
RBInMaine Jan 2017 #285
bravenak Jan 2017 #286
EffieBlack Jan 2017 #15
tecelote Jan 2017 #19
bravenak Jan 2017 #30
tecelote Jan 2017 #33
bravenak Jan 2017 #37
tecelote Jan 2017 #40
bravenak Jan 2017 #41
tecelote Jan 2017 #46
bravenak Jan 2017 #49
KPN Jan 2017 #215
bravenak Jan 2017 #244
forjusticethunders Jan 2017 #273
bravenak Jan 2017 #277
EffieBlack Jan 2017 #71
Gothmog Jan 2017 #94
brush Jan 2017 #153
LisaM Jan 2017 #21
randome Jan 2017 #18
tecelote Jan 2017 #22
randome Jan 2017 #25
tecelote Jan 2017 #28
betsuni Jan 2017 #42
tecelote Jan 2017 #48
betsuni Jan 2017 #59
mcar Jan 2017 #118
randome Jan 2017 #44
tecelote Jan 2017 #51
randome Jan 2017 #54
tecelote Jan 2017 #57
randome Jan 2017 #61
tecelote Jan 2017 #65
randome Jan 2017 #67
LineLineLineLineLineLineReply Sanders was on the ballot in 2016 and under performed Clinton
Gothmog Jan 2017 #98
kacekwl Jan 2017 #139
kacekwl Jan 2017 #141
RazBerryBeret Jan 2017 #133
randome Jan 2017 #202
RazBerryBeret Jan 2017 #237
Gothmog Jan 2017 #250
womanofthehills Jan 2017 #282
LisaM Jan 2017 #60
tecelote Jan 2017 #64
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #260
LisaM Jan 2017 #268
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #271
brush Jan 2017 #154
Orsino Jan 2017 #274
Gothmog Jan 2017 #276
George II Jan 2017 #63
Gothmog Jan 2017 #96
Gothmog Jan 2017 #91
GreenPartyVoter Jan 2017 #122
putitinD Jan 2017 #252
melman Jan 2017 #2
betsuni Jan 2017 #5
Cha Jan 2017 #7
bravenak Jan 2017 #9
betsuni Jan 2017 #43
bravenak Jan 2017 #45
SidDithers Jan 2017 #80
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #6
bravenak Jan 2017 #10
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #23
Gothmog Jan 2017 #97
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #114
Gothmog Jan 2017 #131
tonedevil Jan 2017 #147
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #160
Gothmog Jan 2017 #191
yardwork Jan 2017 #195
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #197
Gothmog Jan 2017 #220
yardwork Jan 2017 #194
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #198
yardwork Jan 2017 #224
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #238
bravenak Jan 2017 #245
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #267
Gothmog Jan 2017 #222
Uponthegears Jan 2017 #161
Gothmog Jan 2017 #189
seaglass Jan 2017 #13
bravenak Jan 2017 #14
UCmeNdc Jan 2017 #31
bravenak Jan 2017 #38
George II Jan 2017 #72
Quayblue Jan 2017 #112
Chasstev365 Jan 2017 #27
Buckeye_Democrat Jan 2017 #47
bravenak Jan 2017 #50
Gothmog Jan 2017 #100
Red Oak Jan 2017 #52
bravenak Jan 2017 #53
JHan Jan 2017 #55
bravenak Jan 2017 #56
JCanete Jan 2017 #230
JHan Jan 2017 #231
JCanete Jan 2017 #232
JHan Jan 2017 #233
JCanete Jan 2017 #234
JHan Jan 2017 #239
George II Jan 2017 #62
baldguy Jan 2017 #70
baldguy Jan 2017 #69
Post removed Jan 2017 #74
JHan Jan 2017 #77
Buckeye_Democrat Jan 2017 #78
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #75
liquid diamond Jan 2017 #87
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #89
liquid diamond Jan 2017 #146
Gothmog Jan 2017 #99
immoderate Jan 2017 #107
Gothmog Jan 2017 #134
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #110
JHan Jan 2017 #115
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #119
JHan Jan 2017 #121
Gothmog Jan 2017 #125
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #128
Gothmog Jan 2017 #132
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #138
R B Garr Jan 2017 #192
Talk Is Cheap Jan 2017 #201
R B Garr Jan 2017 #203
R B Garr Jan 2017 #193
guillaumeb Jan 2017 #79
SidDithers Jan 2017 #82
NobodyHere Jan 2017 #83
Gothmog Jan 2017 #95
Gothmog Jan 2017 #90
HassleCat Jan 2017 #103
baldguy Jan 2017 #120
HassleCat Jan 2017 #149
Post removed Jan 2017 #155
HassleCat Jan 2017 #159
baldguy Jan 2017 #162
HassleCat Jan 2017 #164
baldguy Jan 2017 #165
HassleCat Jan 2017 #166
m-lekktor Jan 2017 #127
HassleCat Jan 2017 #150
50 Shades Of Blue Jan 2017 #104
Post removed Jan 2017 #108
JHan Jan 2017 #111
Post removed Jan 2017 #109
hollowdweller Jan 2017 #113
Garrett78 Jan 2017 #116
mcar Jan 2017 #117
BlueMTexpat Jan 2017 #123
LenaBaby61 Jan 2017 #148
BlueMTexpat Jan 2017 #181
alittlelark Jan 2017 #124
treestar Jan 2017 #129
bravenak Jan 2017 #172
democratisphere Jan 2017 #130
Gothmog Jan 2017 #135
JCanete Jan 2017 #137
democratisphere Jan 2017 #140
JCanete Jan 2017 #144
JCanete Jan 2017 #136
Vermijelli Jan 2017 #167
bravenak Jan 2017 #171
Vermijelli Jan 2017 #185
bravenak Jan 2017 #186
R B Garr Jan 2017 #168
bravenak Jan 2017 #170
R B Garr Jan 2017 #188
melman Jan 2017 #190
ismnotwasm Jan 2017 #169
Post removed Jan 2017 #176
bravenak Jan 2017 #179
Arazi Jan 2017 #180
bravenak Jan 2017 #184
HRC2020 Jan 2017 #196
Chitown Kev Jan 2017 #200
LexVegas Jan 2017 #205
bravenak Jan 2017 #240
yardwork Jan 2017 #241
hueymahl Jan 2017 #214
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #221
R B Garr Jan 2017 #256
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #259
R B Garr Jan 2017 #264
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #270
R B Garr Jan 2017 #272
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #279
R B Garr Jan 2017 #280
bravenak Jan 2017 #246
Gothmog Jan 2017 #248
bravenak Jan 2017 #249
Gothmog Jan 2017 #251
bravenak Jan 2017 #253
R B Garr Jan 2017 #257
Gothmog Jan 2017 #258
hueymahl Jan 2017 #265
bravenak Jan 2017 #266
hueymahl Jan 2017 #269
SMC22307 Jan 2017 #217
Gothmog Jan 2017 #283
bettyellen Jan 2017 #284
sheshe2 Jan 2017 #227
Larkspur Jan 2017 #254
bravenak Jan 2017 #255
Larkspur Jan 2017 #261
bravenak Jan 2017 #263
Larkspur Jan 2017 #287
bravenak Jan 2017 #288
Blue_Tires Jan 2017 #262
Please login to view edit histories.