HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » Latest Breaking News (Forum) » Jerry Nadler condemns 'vi... » Reply #46

Response to still_one (Reply #43)

Fri Aug 23, 2019, 02:43 PM

46. No. He has been defamed as a holocaust denier because he has accused Israel of exploiting

the horrors of the holocaust (experienced in his own family) to justify its racist and inhumane policies.

Dershowitz has had a large hand in discrediting Finkelstein, calling him “not a real Jew” for his being a secular Jew.


Snip——————————————- ( from The Guardian)

And, although The Holocaust Industry is Finkelstein's most frequently cited book in the defamatory attempts to cast him as a "Holocaust denier" and a "denier of justice to Holocaust survivors", Image and Reality in the Israel-Palestine Conflict - a thorough criticism of the central political and philosophical tenets informing Zionism - is his most scholarly and substantial work. But Finkelstein's detractors avoid discussion of Image and Reality for exactly that reason: it is considered a first-rate piece of scholarship. (Bolding mine)

Finkelstein argues that most US commentators obscure or avoid the clear historical and diplomatic record in examining the Israel-Palestine conflict by ignoring or downplaying international law, fooling the US public into believing that Israel's occupation is just, necessary, and lawful. One such example is the failure of the 2000 Camp David talks - a failure that has been attributed, at least in elite circles within the United States, to Yasir Arafat's intransigence. In actuality, what Bill Clinton and Ehud Barak offered Arafat was something no Palestinian leader could accept: a Bantustan state reminiscent of the African national territories.

Finkelstein's latest exposure of US and Israeli apologetics for state violence was of famed Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz, who was at the centre of Finkelstein's analysis in Beyond Chutzpah: The Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History. In August 2003, Dershowitz published The Case for Israel, which Finkelstein uses as a foil in Beyond Chutzpah, demonstrating that Dershowitz misrepresents key diplomatic, legal and historical aspects of the conflict. Dershowitz attempted to block publication of Beyond Chutzpah by inundating the University of California Press with threatening letters from the major New York law firm of Cravath, Swaine, and Moore throughout the spring and summer of 2005, stating he would sue the press if it did not ensure that every claim Finkelstein made about Dershowitz was factually correct. Beyond Chutzpah was vetted by six experts of the Israel-Palestine conflict and several libel attorneys. When he could not prevail upon the press or the University of California's Board of Reagents, Dershowitz asked Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to intervene. Schwarzenegger refused to do so on grounds of academic freedom. Finkelstein wasn't so lucky at DePaul.

End snip——————————————-

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2007/jun/14/abattleforacademicfreedom

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 85 replies Author Time Post
brooklynite Aug 23 OP
exboyfil Aug 23 #1
sandensea Aug 23 #6
question everything Aug 23 #25
BeyondGeography Aug 23 #2
Mosby Aug 23 #22
muriel_volestrangler Aug 23 #35
Igel Aug 24 #62
BuddhaGirl Aug 23 #37
Mosby Aug 23 #54
BuddhaGirl Aug 24 #68
yardwork Aug 25 #75
pnwmom Aug 23 #3
JI7 Aug 23 #14
pnwmom Aug 23 #15
question everything Aug 23 #26
pnwmom Aug 23 #29
Thomas Hurt Aug 25 #77
LanternWaste Aug 29 #84
MontanaMama Aug 23 #4
elleng Aug 23 #5
MontanaMama Aug 23 #7
elleng Aug 23 #8
MontanaMama Aug 23 #9
jayfish Aug 23 #12
Initech Aug 23 #10
stopdiggin Aug 23 #31
question everything Aug 23 #27
Igel Aug 24 #63
treestar Aug 24 #64
DallasNE Aug 23 #11
Grokenstein Aug 23 #34
still_one Aug 23 #41
emmaverybo Aug 23 #42
still_one Aug 23 #43
emmaverybo Aug 23 #44
still_one Aug 23 #45
RhodeIslandOne Aug 24 #73
LineLineLineLineLineLineReply No. He has been defamed as a holocaust denier because he has accused Israel of exploiting
emmaverybo Aug 23 #46
still_one Aug 23 #47
emmaverybo Aug 23 #48
still_one Aug 23 #49
pnwmom Aug 23 #52
still_one Aug 23 #55
pnwmom Aug 23 #57
FreeLookMode Aug 26 #82
pnwmom Aug 23 #51
still_one Aug 23 #39
24601 Aug 25 #74
still_one Aug 25 #76
JI7 Aug 23 #13
pnwmom Aug 23 #16
DallasNE Aug 23 #23
SergeStorms Aug 23 #24
Archae Aug 23 #17
BeyondGeography Aug 23 #19
The Mouth Aug 23 #21
pnwmom Aug 23 #50
JudyM Aug 23 #28
Marengo Aug 23 #30
stopdiggin Aug 23 #33
BeyondGeography Aug 23 #53
treestar Aug 24 #66
Archae Aug 24 #67
treestar Aug 24 #69
Archae Aug 24 #70
treestar Aug 24 #71
BuddhaGirl Aug 24 #72
LuvNewcastle Aug 25 #78
Bettie Aug 26 #80
Mike 03 Aug 23 #18
Mosby Aug 23 #20
matt819 Aug 23 #32
stopdiggin Aug 23 #36
BeyondGeography Aug 23 #38
bluestarone Aug 23 #40
yardwork Aug 23 #60
Owl Aug 25 #79
Bettie Aug 26 #81
njhoneybadger Aug 23 #56
Devil Child Aug 23 #59
treestar Aug 24 #65
Chemisse Aug 23 #58
Schmice3 Aug 24 #61
FreeLookMode Aug 26 #83
Name removed Aug 31 #85
Please login to view edit histories.