Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: "Free State of Jones" [View all]rug
(82,333 posts)21. Thanks for posting that.
Last edited Mon Jul 4, 2016, 07:23 AM - Edit history (1)
I was surprised that this movie even acknowledged the class aspect of the Civil War. The Confederacy was rotten from top to bottom, explicitly benefiting only the wealthy whose wealth and means of production were land and human beings. The scenes of the Confederate quartermasters seizing the corn and pigs of white farmers to fuel its racist army were eye-opening.
It sounds like Blow was describing the movie Glory
The director did not take this movie lightly:
There is evidence that Newt Knight came from a family that opposed the slavocracy on ideological as well as economic grounds. His father had turned down the gift of a slave when he got married, and his declining the economic advantage is telling. Other relatives directly refer to the familys ideological opposition to slavery. 4.1 Like many yeoman farmers, Newt resented a war in which he felt he was fighting to make the rich richer. 4.2
As the war continued, class divisions were exacerbated and became increasingly hard to ignore. Even the common soldier was known to express anger at the planter class and the cotton economy of the slavocracy. In the film, Newt sarcastically goads Sumrall when he claims they are fighting for honor: Well, thats good, Will, 'cause Id sure hate to be fighting for cotton. It was hardly a rare sentiment. 4.3
Threatened with the draft, Newt served in the Confederate Army but refused to fight. As he said I didnt want to fight. I told 'em Id help nurse sick soldiers if they wanted.
http://freestateofjones.info/
As the war continued, class divisions were exacerbated and became increasingly hard to ignore. Even the common soldier was known to express anger at the planter class and the cotton economy of the slavocracy. In the film, Newt sarcastically goads Sumrall when he claims they are fighting for honor: Well, thats good, Will, 'cause Id sure hate to be fighting for cotton. It was hardly a rare sentiment. 4.3
Threatened with the draft, Newt served in the Confederate Army but refused to fight. As he said I didnt want to fight. I told 'em Id help nurse sick soldiers if they wanted.
http://freestateofjones.info/
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
37 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
My conservative brother in law is a grand (to some level) nephew of Newton Knight.
Thor_MN
Jul 2016
#3
Wow, he should read up on his uncle, not to mention what else was going in the county then.
rug
Jul 2016
#4
Because they have to teach about the great Newt Gingrich... at least they do in Texas.
Hoppy
Jul 2016
#8
Snap! LOL, I should read all the way through the thread before popping off
Brother Buzz
Jul 2016
#18
There were also Unionist enclaves in North Alabama, East Tennessee, and elsewhere nt
Ex Lurker
Jul 2016
#20
"What if you could have slavery, the Civil War, Reconstruction, black pain, black murder,
Brickbat
Jul 2016
#9
He was just the vehicle to tell an astounding story. (The $65MM budget needed some insurance.)
rug
Jul 2016
#12
She complains but Henry Gates, the Legal Defense Fund, Andrew Young, etc. have all praised the movie
MinnieBlum
Jul 2016
#36
The director has a website that compares scenes in the movie to the historical record.
rug
Jul 2016
#23
Most people that even think about the Civil War are extremely polarized in the same camps.
TexasProgresive
Jul 2016
#29
Wow that's impressive. When I listened to the book I remeber reading reviews of it
underpants
Jul 2016
#32