Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: If there's one thing I simply cannot stand, it's poverty shaming. [View all]Lydia Leftcoast
(48,217 posts)62. Myths that really frost me because I have to debunk them again and again
1. People on food stamps buy steak and lobster while I (the right-wing person) can't afford them. I won't have people buying steak and lobster at the expense of us poor, strapped taxpayers!
Such wingers seem to assume that food stamp recipients can just go get more when their EBT funds run out. They don't realize that their monthly allotment is their monthly allotment and that they can't go and get more if they run out. They're stuck till the next month. It would be stupid for a food stamp recipient to buy steak and lobster on limited funds, but from the taxpayer's point of view, it's no different than if the recipient lives entirely on rice and beans. The cost to the taxpayer is exactly the same.
2. The "Obama Phone"
Never mind that this is just an updated form of a program that was started by Ronald Reagan. Never mind that the phone comes with limited minutes and no Internet service. The righties' fevered imaginations picture teenage mothers walking around with free iPhone 6's.
What the righties forget is that you can get a smartphone for free if you sign up for a monthly plan and accept an outdated model. This is cheaper than a land line, and I doubt that the average right winger can tell the difference between a 2015 Samsung phone and a 2012 Samsung phone or between an iPhone 5C (available free with contract) and an iPhone 6 (starting at $299 with contract).
3. Ninety-fve percent of so-called poor people have refrigerators, and the majority have air conditioning! I can't afford air conditioning!
Landlords are required by law to provide refrigerators in their apartments, and most apartments these days are either built with air conditioning or (like my older building) have rattly old window models installed.
4. "But they have DVD players!"
I suppose these complainers bought their DVD player when the things were new and cost $500. Well, they cost about $30 now, and with movies only $1.25 at RedBox or free from the public library, there's no cheaper entertainment available other than books from the library. But anyway, as all right-wingers know, poor people aren't supposed to have fun.
Such wingers seem to assume that food stamp recipients can just go get more when their EBT funds run out. They don't realize that their monthly allotment is their monthly allotment and that they can't go and get more if they run out. They're stuck till the next month. It would be stupid for a food stamp recipient to buy steak and lobster on limited funds, but from the taxpayer's point of view, it's no different than if the recipient lives entirely on rice and beans. The cost to the taxpayer is exactly the same.
2. The "Obama Phone"
Never mind that this is just an updated form of a program that was started by Ronald Reagan. Never mind that the phone comes with limited minutes and no Internet service. The righties' fevered imaginations picture teenage mothers walking around with free iPhone 6's.
What the righties forget is that you can get a smartphone for free if you sign up for a monthly plan and accept an outdated model. This is cheaper than a land line, and I doubt that the average right winger can tell the difference between a 2015 Samsung phone and a 2012 Samsung phone or between an iPhone 5C (available free with contract) and an iPhone 6 (starting at $299 with contract).
3. Ninety-fve percent of so-called poor people have refrigerators, and the majority have air conditioning! I can't afford air conditioning!
Landlords are required by law to provide refrigerators in their apartments, and most apartments these days are either built with air conditioning or (like my older building) have rattly old window models installed.
4. "But they have DVD players!"
I suppose these complainers bought their DVD player when the things were new and cost $500. Well, they cost about $30 now, and with movies only $1.25 at RedBox or free from the public library, there's no cheaper entertainment available other than books from the library. But anyway, as all right-wingers know, poor people aren't supposed to have fun.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
91 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
If there's one thing I simply cannot stand, it's poverty shaming. [View all]
Tommy_Carcetti
Apr 2015
OP
Welfare queens and their Cadillacs has long been a right wing lie, now they are claiming they go
liberal N proud
Apr 2015
#2
I don't think their anger is directed specifically at poor persons getting cruses.
Half-Century Man
Apr 2015
#26
A jump to conclusion may be this mother may be trying to provide her children food and we know
Thinkingabout
Apr 2015
#3
THERE BUT FOR THE GRACE OF GOD GO I. Attacks on the poor receiving public assistance have increased
appalachiablue
Apr 2015
#6
Very, very true. I owned a Lexus for 19 years; it took us through thick and thin, never
Nay
Apr 2015
#65
I once went by a welfare office where a co-workers said they were all in late model cars
happyslug
Apr 2015
#56
The Facebook lady is a victim of a cruel misinformation campaign being waged by the
Enthusiast
Apr 2015
#11
For fear that one undeserving person might get aid, Republicans are willing to let millions starve.
tclambert
Apr 2015
#14
That story brings tears to my eyes. What terrible terrible people. What would Jesus say?
Ed Suspicious
Apr 2015
#44
You mean you don't want approved stores that sell plain clothes and cheap goods?
nolabear
Apr 2015
#17
The only assumption here seemed to be that the woman picking up the groceries was not poor at all.
merrily
Apr 2015
#18
Yes, immediately jumping to that conclusion is wrong, but it's not saying a thing about the poor.
merrily
Apr 2015
#25
It's one of those situations though where it's best to keep one's mouth shut.
Tommy_Carcetti
Apr 2015
#39
My Reply 25 said jumping to the conclusion that someone is not poor (not in need) is wrong.
merrily
Apr 2015
#48
If someone is poor, and has a car as good or better than the one they drive, then it's possible that
Amimnoch
Apr 2015
#31
Ditto- I wish they would tell us how poor people are the problem, not the Koch Bros, etal
NoJusticeNoPeace
Apr 2015
#52
If this isn't the last word on poverty and wealth distribution (Comment on Ambrose copied fromWiki),
Joe Chi Minh
Apr 2015
#35
I feel the same way. People are always making excuses for their own miserable lives.
Voice for Peace
Apr 2015
#54
I've met poor whites that are CONVINCED there is a type of welfare only available to blacks.
Spitfire of ATJ
Apr 2015
#57
Myths that really frost me because I have to debunk them again and again
Lydia Leftcoast
Apr 2015
#62
From what I see on discussion boards, and, mind you, I know they're not the world...
NancyDL
Apr 2015
#66
Without a big down payment, a friend couldn't finance a used car unless
lexington filly
Apr 2015
#75
Plenty of people feel jealous that others are getting more than they deserve
IronLionZion
Apr 2015
#83
This started with the Reagan administration in the 1980s, specifically to make us resent the poor
DesertDiamond
Apr 2015
#85
I saw this also posted on my Facebook page today and it makes a lot more sense to me.
Tommy_Carcetti
Apr 2015
#87