HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Mental Illness, Evil, and... » Reply #12
In the discussion thread: Mental Illness, Evil, and Blame [View all]

Response to The Velveteen Ocelot (Reply #11)

Wed Apr 3, 2013, 05:33 PM

12. Yes, that was precisely the case I referred to in the OP

The OP was an effort to defuse the barely-coherent rage that consumes me when people make the off-the-cuff assumption that "sickeningly evil" automatically equates to "crazy/mentally ill" and that somehow or other the law is expected to deal with it coherently, consistently, and fairly on that basis.

The man who committed that terrible crime may be mentally ill by a DSM standard, particularly as the APA in its endless quest to get treatment paid for by third-party payers has been 'medicalizing' every conceivable type of disruptive feeling/behavior relationship. He may (although I doubt it) fit one of the many legal definitions related to diminished mental status or capacity, or criminal insanity. But neither of those qualifications actually speaks to whether an actual brain disorder was the predominant basis for his act. Nor yet whether that relates to a diagnosed condition, nor yet whether such a disorder actually rendered him criminally insane by Wisconsin's standard. Nor yet whether qualifying under that standard will "get him off easy" in terms of... what? Punishment for what he did?

Being a person who did what he did is its own punishment. Society's thirst to equate punishment and vengeance with "justice" must not be further integrated into the law, which MUST function above such motivations if it is to advance civilization.

Reading the casual, shocked, uninformed, unthinking references to mental illness and insanity as a factor in that case was a major precipitant of the OP but not the entire underpinning.

pessimistically,
Bright

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 16 replies Author Time Post
TygrBright Apr 2013 OP
elleng Apr 2013 #1
Neoma Apr 2013 #2
liberal_at_heart Apr 2013 #3
TygrBright Apr 2013 #5
Neoma Apr 2013 #4
The Velveteen Ocelot Apr 2013 #6
TygrBright Apr 2013 #7
The Velveteen Ocelot Apr 2013 #11
LineLineLineLineNew Reply Yes, that was precisely the case I referred to in the OP
TygrBright Apr 2013 #12
The Velveteen Ocelot Apr 2013 #13
davidthegnome Apr 2013 #8
TygrBright Apr 2013 #10
winter is coming Apr 2013 #9
caseymoz Apr 2013 #14
libodem Apr 2013 #15
BainsBane Apr 2013 #16
Please login to view edit histories.