Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

joemacdawson

(61 posts)
6. It Depends
Thu Sep 15, 2022, 12:38 AM
Sep 2022

Music means different things for different people. It depends what you’re looking for.
Rush, obviously I think, were technically the most skilled band. Innovative even. AC/DC were the most fun band. A three chord bar band writ large. But I think The Clash were the most socially and culturally important band. At least politically. And they’ll be the band best remembered generations from now. Like Dylan and Elvis and the Beatles, they stirred the pot. They shook things up. And inspired others to do the same. Closer To The Heart and Shook Me All Night Long are well recorded fun songs but they wont be remembered like Know Your Rights or even the cover, I Fought The Law (and the Law Won).

AC/DC, Rush, The Clash Skittles Sep 2022 #1
The Clash - London Calling Celerity Sep 2022 #16
You are so.lucky! bedazzled Sep 2022 #26
Rush, then the Clash. MatthewG. Sep 2022 #2
I agree with you 100 percent. ArnoldLayne Sep 2022 #3
This is tough AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2022 #4
Among those three? johnp3907 Sep 2022 #5
+1 Celerity Sep 2022 #10
Ha! Indeed.... nt Carlitos Brigante Sep 2022 #17
I love The Clash Dorian Gray Sep 2022 #23
Damn straight! Sky Jewels Sep 2022 #36
Gotta agree. scarletlib Sep 2022 #37
LOL treestar Sep 2022 #42
It Depends joemacdawson Sep 2022 #6
On YouTube right now, on the official Clash Channel, ZZenith Sep 2022 #14
100% lock The Clash will be FAR more remembered, influential, and culturally important than Rush Celerity Sep 2022 #19
Total album sales: ZZenith Sep 2022 #46
those figures for the Clash are bollocks, apparently culled from some dodgy rando Russian site: Celerity Sep 2022 #47
I hope you know this is all in good fun and I mean no offense ZZenith Sep 2022 #52
of, yes of course, every person has their own tastes, but I also would not reduce The Clash Celerity Sep 2022 #57
That's a 3 chord song you just posted. ZZenith Sep 2022 #61
Anecdotal Counter Fact ProfessorGAC Sep 2022 #72
100% lock The Clash will be FAR more remembered, influential, and culturally important than Rush Celerity Sep 2022 #20
This message was self-deleted by its author Sky Jewels Sep 2022 #34
+1 treestar Sep 2022 #43
great response Celerity Sep 2022 #49
Love their music. scarletlib Sep 2022 #67
The Clash fishwax Sep 2022 #7
Rush -- keep the rest Earth-shine Sep 2022 #8
The Clash, The Clash and The Clash... BigmanPigman Sep 2022 #9
Rush way out in front. Not even close. Wingus Dingus Sep 2022 #11
Rush...................The ClashAC/DC .. AC/DCThe Clash (Doesn't matter) ZZenith Sep 2022 #12
AC/DC their album is so good... jcgoldie Sep 2022 #13
LOL! ZZenith Sep 2022 #15
Angus Young agrees. Captain Stern Sep 2022 #27
LOL. :) MatthewG. Sep 2022 #73
Rush, AC/DC GoodRaisin Sep 2022 #18
The Clash, AC/DC and I'm done. ZonkerHarris Sep 2022 #21
Same. Act_of_Reparation Sep 2022 #28
AC/DC, The Clash, Rush Straw Man Sep 2022 #22
Led Zeppelin, AC/DC, The Clash meadowlander Sep 2022 #24
I put AC/DC first with bon scott ... last without bedazzled Sep 2022 #25
My favorite cat is a puppy. 48656c6c6f20 Sep 2022 #29
My favorite puppy is a kitten. Sky Jewels Sep 2022 #39
AC/DC , the Clash, Rush lark Sep 2022 #30
AC/DC, The Clash, Rush emulatorloo Sep 2022 #31
I went to the very first concert by The Clash in the USA (Berkeley). Not my last show. Just A Box Of Rain Sep 2022 #32
The Clash - #1 Sky Jewels Sep 2022 #33
I'd rather stick ice picks in my ears than listen to Rush. Sky Jewels Sep 2022 #35
Of the three, The Clash is best, by far Beausoleil Sep 2022 #38
Same. Joe was amazing. Sky Jewels Sep 2022 #40
I love Big Audio Dynamite too Celerity Sep 2022 #53
This message was self-deleted by its author Celerity Sep 2022 #54
rush the clash and the acdc moonshinegnomie Sep 2022 #41
My thoughts Stratman Sep 2022 #44
This should be lounge! USALiberal Sep 2022 #45
Yea I know ArnoldLayne Sep 2022 #63
The Clash is the only band that matters Retrograde Sep 2022 #48
Let's see. gldstwmn Sep 2022 #50
Back In Black, Moving Pictures/Presto, Combat Rock Brainfodder Sep 2022 #51
The Clash are in top 5 greatest rock bands ever territory. The others are not. nt LexVegas Sep 2022 #55
According to whom? ZZenith Sep 2022 #56
says who? Skittles Sep 2022 #58
Rush, AC/DC, The Clash Deep State Witch Sep 2022 #59
New Order Goodheart Sep 2022 #60
Like the Clash quite a bit, Rush is at least interesting, and AC/DC is kind of fun mvd Sep 2022 #62
One more thing I'll say about Rush MatthewG. Sep 2022 #64
Thank you. ZZenith Sep 2022 #66
Good article. MatthewG. Sep 2022 #68
+1 leftstreet Sep 2022 #69
You are welcome! And I agree Rush was truly unique among rock bands. MatthewG. Sep 2022 #70
The Clash, the Clash, the Clash iemanja Sep 2022 #65
Apples, oranges or kiwi fruit. In what order and why? highplainsdem Sep 2022 #71
My list ForgedCrank Sep 2022 #74
Locking JudyM Sep 2022 #75
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Rush, The Clash or AC/DC ...»Reply #6