Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

neeksgeek

(1,214 posts)
26. Oh my, what a great idea! Not really...
Mon Aug 26, 2019, 07:41 AM
Aug 2019

A typical hurricane expends more energy per second than the Little Boy (Hirosima) bomb’s total output. The energy in a hurricane is immense. I’m sure that a given storm could be scattered by a big enough explosion (or series of smaller ones), but the energy is still there in the warm water. A hurricane isn’t some external object like an asteroid about to hit earth, it’s part of the climate’s equilibrium.

In short, we’d never be able to stop them all without more nuclear explosions than all the tests we’ve done!

Editing to add: worst case scenario, a nuke doesn’t do anything but make a radioactive hurricane. Doesn’t that sound like fun???

Back in the early atomic age, all sorts of uses for nuclear power were explored. Using atomic weapons to blast paths through mountains for new highways; launching spacecraft on a pillar of atomic explosions (a “nuclear pulse rocket” - AKA Project Orion). Et cetera. These outlandish ideas have seen some use in science fiction, for example in Dune, Paul Atreides uses atomics to blast through a mountain range named the Shield Wall; even in this far-flung futuristic work of fiction, it’s considered a horrible idea.

There are not enough faces and palms for this. uriel1972 Aug 2019 #1
America's face hurts. lunatica Aug 2019 #6
I think we should dump espresso and milk into a hurricane LuvNewcastle Aug 2019 #2
I would need to test this theory on at least 100 hurricanes to say for sure..... KY_EnviroGuy Aug 2019 #3
Yes Tiggeroshii Aug 2019 #4
Eh? nt Tommy_Carcetti Aug 2019 #14
We did the energy calculations on this way back in grad school for a thermo class Recursion Aug 2019 #5
I think Zantac ought to do it. dchill Aug 2019 #7
👍 captain queeg Aug 2019 #17
CIC Trump could surgically N-bomb the hurricane's eye, thereby killing its brain. Then, it NCjack Aug 2019 #29
A hurricane has about 12 billion times the joules than the biggest bomb ever made sakabatou Aug 2019 #8
Those that voted yes are welcome to argue the case or provide a shred of evidence. Doodley Aug 2019 #9
That's what I was wondering. Who are the 3 that feel this is a AllyCat Aug 2019 #10
Could just be satire... Agschmid Aug 2019 #20
There are now 4. Do they know we can see their usernames? Coventina Aug 2019 #39
Best to just vaccinate the hurricanes to give them autism... ExciteBike66 Aug 2019 #11
*snicker* smirkymonkey Aug 2019 #21
I thought this would be our first poll with 100% no's. pnwmom Aug 2019 #12
+1 Lulu KC Aug 2019 #32
Expectations are planned disappointments... Wounded Bear Aug 2019 #40
Of course not. Tommy_Carcetti Aug 2019 #13
How about just building a big, beautiful hurricane wall? nt Buns_of_Fire Aug 2019 #15
That actually could help in some areas but that costs a lot of money. LisaL Aug 2019 #18
Great idea as long as we don't mind the nuclear fallout and winter democratisphere Aug 2019 #16
Trump knows big winds... Fyrefox Aug 2019 #19
Why doesn't Trump just "Hereby Order" any hurricanes to turn around and head toward smirkymonkey Aug 2019 #22
Is this part of MAD? Historic NY Aug 2019 #23
Pass. GoCubsGo Aug 2019 #24
No. We'd just have a hurricane with radioactive fallout ck4829 Aug 2019 #25
Oh my, what a great idea! Not really... neeksgeek Aug 2019 #26
Has Trump been watching Sharknado? C_U_L8R Aug 2019 #27
He has been itching to use nukes somewhere, some how captain queeg Aug 2019 #28
I can see wondering about that. But most people realize it's a dumb idea and don't say it. n/t brewens Aug 2019 #30
Absolutely not. It will only create more giant fire-breathing Godzillas and extremely large ants dameatball Aug 2019 #31
Maybe... Newest Reality Aug 2019 #33
Just send "the chosen one" out there in a duck floatie and let him blow it out. BluesRunTheGame Aug 2019 #34
Didn"t Nixon drop a regular bomb on one? scarytomcat Aug 2019 #35
We need another category - IMO lark Aug 2019 #36
Hurricanes are bad and can cause a lot of devastation Proud Liberal Dem Aug 2019 #37
Scientists have done the calculations. It won't work period and would be the ultimate dirty bomb Quixote1818 Aug 2019 #38
Why would someone vote yes? DemocratSinceBirth Aug 2019 #41
Now MF45 denies that he suggested nuking hurricanes Niagara Aug 2019 #42
I believe "Radioactive Hurricane" is a dandy nickname for Donald struggle4progress Aug 2019 #43
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Do you believe nuking hur...»Reply #26