Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

ehrnst

(32,640 posts)
13. Single payer is used by very few countries to achieve Universal Health Care. Most use hybrid payers.
Thu Jul 4, 2019, 09:48 AM
Jul 2019

To attack anyone at all who points out that Single Payer took decades to get up to speed in the few countries where it is used, or to point out the problems with Bernie Sanders' timeline and cost estimates as "greedy fuckers" isn't factual or productive.

We are working towards universal health care as the goal. If we can get there faster with a multi-payer plan, with some private elements like the vast majority of the rest of the industrialized world, that would be preferable than a bill that will likely meet the same fate as the requirement for Medicaid expansion did. If the 2010 SCOTUS struck down the ACA's mandate that states expand Medicaid to more poor people, even if the Federal Government paid for it, how do you think the current SCOTUS will rule on the inevitable challenge to a law that requires the expansion of Medicare AND Medicaid to everyone? Look at how the GOP was able to kneecap some of the many parts of the ACA.

We should not make mistake that anti-choicers make, by dismissing/demonizing health care policy experts as "shills of the Planned Parenthood and the abortion industry" who say that getting rid of Planned Parenthood will not stop abortions, and in fact, may increase their numbers and make them more dangerous. Their first goal stopped being to reduce abortion, and became "punishing the greedy doctors and those promiscuous women" rejecting any strategy, no matter how effective, that doesn't eliminate Planned Parenthood and criminalize providers.

(No, I'm not comparing Planned Parenthood to private insurance providers. I'm comparing the tribal thinking that the "solution" has become dogma, and demonizes anyone who points out the problems in that "solution" as heretics, "stupid," and/or "greedy bastards."

There are ways to get affordable health care to more people that would be quicker and more efficient than a bill that can't deliver what it promises, as per non-partisan, self-funded health care policy think tanks and experts.

I will believe those experts over a political promise any day.

I understand your anger. I have only in the last 15 years gotten out of horrific debt because of medical bills as an uninsured person just out of college who landed in the hospital for two weeks with two bleeding ulcers, then again 3 years later for a week for the very same.

Yes, our health care system is fucked up. Like the issue of emancipation, there may not be a solution that doesn't create more problems in other aspects of health care and the economy, or hurt other people. It's a 'wicked problem" that defies a single simple answer, no matter what the intentions of a politician who promises one.



Be sure and vote True Blue American Jul 2019 #1
USA! USA! dalton99a Jul 2019 #2
Wow! All I can say is, at least we're not Ireland FakeNoose Jul 2019 #12
Ireland jumped out to me too Midnightwalk Jul 2019 #29
Interesting because I'm in France and covered under that system. GoneOffShore Jul 2019 #40
Best healthcare in the world, asccording to the entitled Scarsdale Jul 2019 #3
Thank you for your post. I know what you mean. Ohioboy Jul 2019 #4
Yep cilla4progress Jul 2019 #5
How come errors like this always go in favor of the rich corporations? Farmer-Rick Jul 2019 #6
Tri Care is great. Ligyron Jul 2019 #17
Yes, it is pretty good Farmer-Rick Jul 2019 #32
Yes totally fucked up vlyons Jul 2019 #7
Please support area51 Jul 2019 #8
We had a flexible spending account onlyadream Jul 2019 #9
Like so many things today... El Mimbreno Jul 2019 #10
Don't get sick and if you do, die quickly. panader0 Jul 2019 #11
Single payer is used by very few countries to achieve Universal Health Care. Most use hybrid payers. ehrnst Jul 2019 #13
K&R. Agree, and thank you for that clarity. KY_EnviroGuy Jul 2019 #19
A clear result of an unfettered laissez-faire version of capitalism. KY_EnviroGuy Jul 2019 #14
After getting a brain injury that sent me into seizures medical bills were a nightmare ... uponit7771 Jul 2019 #15
Is this for a business? Or you have multiple ins. plans just for yourself? Honeycombe8 Jul 2019 #16
Answers: LuckyCharms Jul 2019 #18
Oh, yeah. I remember what FSA is. Honeycombe8 Jul 2019 #21
FSA are still around in some workplace plans. MarvinGardens Jul 2019 #23
I remember that. That's mainly why I didn't participate. Honeycombe8 Jul 2019 #25
I have an FSA plan... druidity33 Jul 2019 #28
Mine works fine for prescriptions... LuckyCharms Jul 2019 #30
I use durable medical stuff, so we put in all we're allowed. Lars39 Jul 2019 #31
I feel your pain, Lucky Ohiogal Jul 2019 #20
Sounds like Blue Cross. MarvinGardens Jul 2019 #22
Healthcare made easy PoliWrangler Jul 2019 #24
There will be nothing "easy" about changing our baked in patchwork unregulated system, ehrnst Jul 2019 #26
It's not enough that you're sick, CrispyQ Jul 2019 #27
Hear! Hear! k&r n/t Laelth Jul 2019 #33
Yep. I have five possible payers.. lostnfound Jul 2019 #34
We all waste time becoming proficient in multiple payer systems lostnfound Jul 2019 #35
"Waste time?" Most developed nations have multi payer systems for UHC. ehrnst Jul 2019 #36
I think you misunderstood me..complexity is burdensome. Many people can't cope. lostnfound Jul 2019 #37
Gotcha. ehrnst Jul 2019 #38
As you personally experienced, it's not mixed payer the way some other countries are, where.. lostnfound Jul 2019 #39
This is exactly what I experienced... Phentex Jul 2019 #41
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I just spent two hours wo...»Reply #13