Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

struggle4progress

(118,282 posts)
20. Trump deserves impeachment, but failure would harm Constitution
Wed Apr 24, 2019, 01:00 PM
Apr 2019

Apr 24, 2019
by Michael Sean Winters

I was wrong. I thought that someone like Attorney General William Barr would not misrepresent the findings of the Mueller report on Russian meddling in the 2016 investigation. He did.

I was also wrong to think that Mueller's statement — repeated by Barr, that while his report did not exonerate President Trump of the charge of obstruction of justice, he was not recommending action one way or the other, but leaving that determination to the attorney general and Congress — was the result of the difficulty in proving intent, especially because the president so often behaves like a 4-year-old. The report clearly indicates that the president wanted to obstruct justice. His top aides were unwilling to act on his orders because doing so would have involved them in criminal activity. The lack of actual obstruction was the result of his aides acting on their own, ignoring the president.

I was not wrong to think that impeachment remains a bridge too far. The president's actions certainly warrant impeachment proceedings in the House and conviction in the Senate. But, Sen. Mitch McConnell, the majority leader, is as indifferent to constitutional norms in his way as the president is in his. A failure to convict the president, despite ample evidence of lying and disregard for the law, would be seen as a vindication of the president.

When Speaker Nancy Pelosi said "He isn't worth it" in explaining her desire to avoid impeachment, it was to this reality that she was speaking. Trump has endangered so many democratic norms already. Whether the Democrats were to pursue impeachment or not, either decision will also devalue the impeachment process itself, even though it was designed precisely for situations like this. He isn't worth it. And, let history be as unkind to McConnell as it will be to Trump ...

https://www.ncronline.org/news/opinion/distinctly-catholic/trump-deserves-impeachment-failure-would-harm-constitution

Bad time to impeach? What history says. struggle4progress Apr 2019 #1
Maxine Waters: We're going to have to impeach struggle4progress Apr 2019 #2
It is only a question of time. "When to impeach?"...not..."If to impeach?" Stuart G Apr 2019 #16
Hillary Clinton: Anyone but Trump would have been indicted struggle4progress Apr 2019 #3
Hillary Clinton says Nancy Pelosi is 'right to be cautious' on impeaching Trump struggle4progress Apr 2019 #4
No time for caution... impeach the Obstructionist-in-Chief now!! InAbLuEsTaTe Apr 2019 #9
'We have very good reason' to impeach Trump, Kamala Harris says struggle4progress Apr 2019 #5
Pelosi: Dems may get to impeachment, but 'we're not there yet' struggle4progress Apr 2019 #6
GOP congressman Peter King 'almost hopes' Democrats push for impeachment struggle4progress Apr 2019 #7
Former Trump transition team member says it's time to impeach Trump struggle4progress Apr 2019 #8
Trump tweet about impeachment confuses political conclusions with legal ones struggle4progress Apr 2019 #10
Lindsey Graham tells Trump to 'expect impeachment proceedings' struggle4progress Apr 2019 #11
Investigation is the new impeachment struggle4progress Apr 2019 #12
More Democrats making case for impeachment struggle4progress Apr 2019 #13
Trump Threatens to Get His Cousins If Democrats Keep Threatening Impeachment struggle4progress Apr 2019 #14
Threat to go to court over impeachment defies 1993 ruling struggle4progress Apr 2019 #15
Trump on Democratic investigations: 'We're fighting all the subpoenas' struggle4progress Apr 2019 #17
George W. Bush's top speechwriter is now calling for Trump's impeachment struggle4progress Apr 2019 #18
Making his own impeachment more likely struggle4progress Apr 2019 #19
Trump deserves impeachment, but failure would harm Constitution struggle4progress Apr 2019 #20
Packed room at a 'Need To Impeach' town hall meeting in Pleasanton CA struggle4progress Apr 2019 #21
Could Donald Trump be impeached? struggle4progress Apr 2019 #22
Democrats weigh principle against popularity struggle4progress Apr 2019 #23
Republican who worked to impeach Nixon challenging Trump for the presidency struggle4progress Apr 2019 #24
Nice collection of articles Poiuyt Apr 2019 #25
Rick Wilson makes a very valid point that should be understood by all those calling for impeachment. OnDoutside Apr 2019 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I am done being wishy-was...»Reply #20