Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 11:45 AM Nov 2017

Clemson #1, Alabama #5 in polls - defies all logic!

Clemson has a loss to an unranked 4-8 team.

Alabama has an away loss to a 9-2 #6 team (which is now ranked ahead of Alabama with 2 losses? ).

We'll see if the Playoff Selection Committee brings some mental consistency to this insanity.

If the record doesn't count, why play all those games?

The one saving grace - any of the top 4 teams lose, Alabama would bump up into the Final Four. Logically, that is.

32 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Clemson #1, Alabama #5 in polls - defies all logic! (Original Post) yallerdawg Nov 2017 OP
As a Georgian, I am required to despise Alabama above all else Glorfindel Nov 2017 #1
As an Alabamian, remarkably... yallerdawg Nov 2017 #2
Better Old Crank Nov 2017 #3
Week after week after week, Alabama proved it on the field. yallerdawg Nov 2017 #4
Couple of points. underpants Nov 2017 #5
Auburn played Mercer, too. yallerdawg Nov 2017 #6
Good info. underpants Nov 2017 #7
If Georgia beats Auburn... yallerdawg Nov 2017 #8
That's a good point but UGA will still be a 1 loss conference champion underpants Nov 2017 #9
they aren't going to want d_r Nov 2017 #11
Auburn was "Game of the Year" for LSU nt d_r Nov 2017 #12
early loss better than late loss d_r Nov 2017 #10
I'd hate to see even more games. yallerdawg Nov 2017 #13
Naw d_r Nov 2017 #17
11 + 1 Conf + 1 Round of 8 + 1 Round of Four + 1 Final equals 15 games! yallerdawg Nov 2017 #19
Its the same d_r Nov 2017 #21
Even simpler d_r Nov 2017 #18
Then start paying the players... yallerdawg Nov 2017 #20
Already do it, so why not d_r Nov 2017 #22
honestly d_r Nov 2017 #23
1978, USC beat Alabama More_Cowbell Nov 2017 #14
Well, now, that's a grudge. yallerdawg Nov 2017 #15
There is one AD on the selection committee, want to guess which school SCantiGOP Nov 2017 #16
Auburn is OUT. Pretty sure. trof Dec 2017 #24
I have such conflicting emotions! yallerdawg Dec 2017 #25
Go Canes voteearlyvoteoften Dec 2017 #26
Go Canes yes MaryMagdaline Dec 2017 #27
Alabama is out Watchfoxheadexplodes Dec 2017 #28
Clemson/Miami winner is in ClarendonDem Dec 2017 #29
You can't take Wisconsin over Ohio State if OSU wins exboyfil Dec 2017 #31
If teams were supposed to jump No. 5 Alabama... yallerdawg Dec 2017 #32
It might come down to Alabama or Ohio State exboyfil Dec 2017 #30

Glorfindel

(9,706 posts)
1. As a Georgian, I am required to despise Alabama above all else
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 11:55 AM
Nov 2017

but I agree with you, and feel your pain. On the other hand, as a Georgian, I have had lots of experience in graciously accepting losses, last-second or blowout (the heartbreak of this year's Superbowl comes to mind, among many, many others). So, please, do yourself no damage, and remember that tomorrow is another day.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
2. As an Alabamian, remarkably...
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 12:07 PM
Nov 2017

I'll be rooting for Georgia this weekend!

It's hard to see that Georgia head coach losing to the same team twice (he didn't do it when he was with Alabama)!

And after teams play Alabama, they seem to need a lot of time to lick their wounds.

Of course, the Dawgs have that one terrible ass-kickin' on their record, so, you know, Alabama still looks shinier!

Old Crank

(3,375 posts)
3. Better
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 12:13 PM
Nov 2017

I thought you proved yourself on the field. Alabama is not based on that better than Auburn. Don't worry the selection group will keep Alabama in the final 4.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
4. Week after week after week, Alabama proved it on the field.
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 12:23 PM
Nov 2017

"Better" is not determined by one game on one Saturday.

Otherwise, let's just skip to the Iron Bowl each season, and send the SEC rep to the Championship based on that.

Check the record.

underpants

(182,279 posts)
5. Couple of points.
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 12:39 PM
Nov 2017

First, as much as everyone cries about not scheduling cupcakes now you can't have two losses or it's the end of the world.

Second, Auburn has the hardest strength of schedule (below) and beat Bama head to head. You can lose but just don't lose late in the season. Bama does not even have a conference championship either.

https://www.teamrankings.com/college-football/ranking/schedule-strength-by-other
Really Bama, Colorado State and Mercer?

Lastly, the winner of the SEC and ACC championship games look to be a lock to get into the playoff. If Oklahoma wins the Big 12 they'll be in too. Should TCU beat them that could open the door for Alabama. The big question is the Big 10 - if Wisconsin wins they're in if THE Ohio Sate wins things could get dicey for Alabama. They beat 1 team in the top 20 strength of schedule (Miss St is #22) but that was Fla State who are no longer ranked. OSU went 3-2 against the same top 20. Against the current top 25 OSU went 3-1 while Bama went 2-1.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
6. Auburn played Mercer, too.
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 12:54 PM
Nov 2017

And other patsies. Alabama beat LSU. Auburn didn't. Auburn got Alabama and Georgia at home! More luck! Clemson beat them, LSU beat them - on the road. Records matter.

Oklahoma State lost 3 games. Auburn lost 2.

Every time Alabama plays, it is the "Game of the Year" for their opposition. Starting with Florida State (#3 at the time) straight through to Auburn (#6 at the time).

One game does not define the season.

underpants

(182,279 posts)
7. Good info.
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 01:01 PM
Nov 2017

I think the conference championship winners are going to be hard to keep out of the playoffs unless TCU wins - that's Bama's best shot to me.

The SEC just that strong this year top to bottom. The ACC and The Big 10 were clearly stronger conferences this year.

In my opinion.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
8. If Georgia beats Auburn...
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 01:33 PM
Nov 2017

how would they leapfrog Alabama?

Their one loss was a royal ass whippin' against a team Alabama contested right to the end.

And if Georgia should win in the rematch, they have Alabama to thank for softening Auburn up!

What comes to mind was the Alabama championship against LSU a few years back. Alabama skipped that SEC championship, too. And faced the team in the championship game that gave them that one loss.

Alabama in, Georgia in, too, if they beat Auburn - or move up to #5, tough break.

Malzahn heads to Arkansas!

underpants

(182,279 posts)
9. That's a good point but UGA will still be a 1 loss conference champion
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 02:00 PM
Nov 2017

I do think that the committee will do everything I can to get Bama in there definitely over TCU and maybe MAYBE over OSU.

d_r

(6,907 posts)
11. they aren't going to want
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 02:07 PM
Nov 2017

two teams from same conference, limits tv ratings and that's what it is all about. If you already have Georgia or Auburn then Alabama doesn't really bring any additional tv viewers to the show (except maybe people watching hoping they lose because they shouldn't have been there in the first place).

d_r

(6,907 posts)
10. early loss better than late loss
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 02:05 PM
Nov 2017

always has been in this popularity contest.

It doesn't really work this way, but the impression is probably Clemson beat Auburn, Auburn beat Alabama.

And of course Auburn is ranked ahead of Alabama, we all saw that with our own two eyes.

The whole idea of a "national champion" in college football, short of an actual play off, is stupid to me. You have 100 something teams that each play 12 games. So, you don't have enough data to actually "pick" the top 2 or 4. If they have to do it, and I'd be fine if they didn't, then they should have an 8-team playoff with only conference champions. The conference championship game becomes a playoff game - want to be in the playoffs, win your conference champions. Some would argue that team B in a given conference is a "better" team than team A in another, and of course they would be correct, but ultimately it doesn't matter if you consider the conference championship as a play in game.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
13. I'd hate to see even more games.
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 02:24 PM
Nov 2017

These "kids" are unpaid amateurs. Yes, they get scholarships most often, but a lot of these programs are comparable to the pros and generate huge financial reward to everyone but the players..

Now "champions" are looking at 15, 16 games? And "success" would be measured by this?

SEC West is superior to SEC East. After 12 games, that one game would determine who goes to the championship series?

I think I prefer consensus polling and analysis of records. Every game counts. 4-8 Syracuse beat Clemson. No pud team beat Alabama.

d_r

(6,907 posts)
17. Naw
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 03:34 PM
Nov 2017

We already have conference championship games in most major Conferences. You could take the regular season from 12 back down to 11 and only miss one whipping post. Then add one week for 8 teams to go down to four.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
19. 11 + 1 Conf + 1 Round of 8 + 1 Round of Four + 1 Final equals 15 games!
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 03:46 PM
Nov 2017

How is that a "Naw?"

Coaches like Saban are saying it's too much - and unfair - now. And when you go to 8, when does #9 get satisfaction? When it's opened up so much anyone can win?

d_r

(6,907 posts)
21. Its the same
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 04:17 PM
Nov 2017

12+1 conf +round of 4 + final champ. game = 15

I'm just saying what would take the qualitative beauty pageant out of it.

If you want to win "national championship" then first win your conference (I couldn't care less what Saban says, but I think he said something like that).

In this scheme, #9 gets to go to a bowl game. If #9 wanted to be in the playoff they should have won their conference to get a slot.

Personally, I'd be happier just having bowl games and everybody arguing about who the mythical national champion was, like it used to be. But, if we are going to pretend that we have a "national champion" then I wish we would take the picking and choosing out and do it in a way that is fair to everyone.

d_r

(6,907 posts)
18. Even simpler
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 03:41 PM
Nov 2017

But it will never happen . Just have eight conferences of 12 teams each. 96 teams is enough for division 1. Each conference has a championship game, each conference champion goes to 8 team playoff. No judgment calls, every game counts.

d_r

(6,907 posts)
22. Already do it, so why not
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 04:20 PM
Nov 2017

I honestly don't see how getting down to 8 conferences of 12 teams each is related to paying players, but whatever. What I'm saying is that every division 1 team would start the year with an equal chance of getting to the final game without subjective picking.

d_r

(6,907 posts)
23. honestly
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 04:23 PM
Nov 2017

I think now the teams are picked by tv ratings potential as much as anything. I think an actual play off would be less about the money than the current system, which is one of the reasons why we'll never see it.

More_Cowbell

(2,190 posts)
14. 1978, USC beat Alabama
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 02:24 PM
Nov 2017

And they ended up tied for the national ranking, SC getting the coaches' poll and Alabama getting the AP poll.

That was my freshman year at USC, and we don't forget. I was rooting for Auburn all the way, last weekend.

SCantiGOP

(13,856 posts)
16. There is one AD on the selection committee, want to guess which school
Mon Nov 27, 2017, 03:07 PM
Nov 2017

Yep, it's Clem's son. And there is a second member of the committee that graduated from Moo U.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
25. I have such conflicting emotions!
Sat Dec 2, 2017, 08:46 PM
Dec 2017

Rooting for Georgia, Miami, and Ohio State, all in one day.

This is as close to hell as I can imagine.



 

ClarendonDem

(720 posts)
29. Clemson/Miami winner is in
Sat Dec 2, 2017, 09:25 PM
Dec 2017

After that, Wisconsin is in if they win. If they lose, then not sure -- Alabama, Ohio State, Auburn, and Wisconsin all have a claim. I'd guess Alabama.

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
32. If teams were supposed to jump No. 5 Alabama...
Sat Dec 2, 2017, 11:38 PM
Dec 2017

if all they had to do was win while Alabama sat idle - why wasn't Alabama ranked 8 or 9?

Logically - if any teams lose ranked higher than Bama, Bama moves up!

exboyfil

(17,857 posts)
30. It might come down to Alabama or Ohio State
Sat Dec 2, 2017, 10:22 PM
Dec 2017

Georgia and Oklahoma are now in. Clemson is dismantling Miami. Ohio State is winning so far against Wisconsin.

One loss but no conference title. USC won today as well. Who has Alabama beat this year? They lost to an Auburn team that got killed by Georgia today.

My Master's alma mater (Iowa) did embarrass Ohio State though. I would pick Alabama because Ohio State went to the playoffs before without winning their conference. One loss beats two losses.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Football»Clemson #1, Alabama #5 in...