Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumE360 On Brazilian Deforestation - It's Much Worse Than It Looks
e360: How does commercial logging factor into the deforestation problem?
Fearnside: Timber extraction doesnt come up in the numbers as deforestation. Its not like clear-cutting in the northwestern U.S., where you cut all the trees and there is basically just bare ground left where there was forest. Here you just take out the most valuable timber and most of the trees are left standing. So the satellite will show it as forest. Nevertheless, it is very important for deforestation, because logging is one of the big sources of money that pays for the people who deforest. Youre selling timber and using the income to clear forest for cattle pasture or plantations. To get the timber out, you also need to build temporary roads that facilitate the entry of people who clear the forest for farms. There are various ways that logging speeds up deforestation.
e360: How much illegal logging is going on?
Fearnside: A lot of the logging is illegal, theres no question. But even if you follow all the regulations to the letter and log legally, its not sustainable, because of all sorts of loopholes that have been put into the regulations. Some companies are granted concessions on federal or state land. To qualify, loggers have to come up with a forest management plan. With forest management, the idea is that you divide up the forest into parcels and you take the big trees out of one parcel one year and out of another in another year. After thirty years you come back to the first parcel and the trees will have grown back and you take out the big ones so thats the idea, you just keep on going round and round and this will be sustainable. So theoretically, you are going to sit there for 30 years doing nothing, with no income before you harvest it again. But nobody is going to do that. Nothing obliges people to do this forever. So you say youve changed your mind, youve decided to clear it for pasture. Other people just sell the land off. Is it likely that the new owner is going to sit there for 30 years waiting for the new forest to grow back? Its just not going to happen. You have these loopholes that have been inserted in the law, so that all of the logging that is happening on paper it is all sustainable, but in practice it really isnt.
EDIT
e360: The Amazon forest is said to create its own climate. Transpiration from the trees creates clouds, which in turn produce rain. What impact does cutting the forest have on rainfall?
Fearnside: You know, there is a big drought now in Sao Paulo. Its not something that you can conclusively pin on deforestation. But a lot of the water in Sao Paulo comes from the Amazon. Its water that has been recycled through the trees, so if you cut [the forest] down and turn it into a cattle pasture, that water isnt going to go to Sao Paulo anymore, it is going to flow straight into the Amazon River, [then] into the Atlantic. If you keep clearing the Amazon, youll end up with there being a permanent drought, not just a one-year thing. Youre not going to have that transport of water vapor to Sao Paulo. It will have a big impact all the way down to Argentina. Argentina is very worried about deforestation in the Amazon. There are also connections to North America and other parts of the world as well, so deforestation would have some effect on rainfall in North America in important agricultural areas in the Midwest, for example.
e360: Recently re-elected Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff has pledged to push rural development. What impact might this agenda have on the Amazon forest?
Fearnside: You have the so-called PAC, the five-year plan for the acceleration of growth. Dilma is known as the mother of the PAC. It consists of a list of projects, building roads and dams and so on, projects that will lead to more deforestation. The most dramatic case is the proposed BR 319 Highway, which would link Manaus in the center of the Amazon with the arc of deforestation in the south, where 80 percent of the deforestation has occurred, along the southern and eastern edges of the forest. If the actors in the arc of deforestation companies, individuals move out of that region into the rest of the forest, it changes everything. It isnt just that one road; a series of side roads that are planned will open up that big block of intact forest in the western Amazon. Once you build a road like that a lot of what happens is no longer under the governments control people moving into the forest and so on. The government may go after them, but it usually ends up legalizing what has happened.
EDIT
http://e360.yale.edu/feature/what_lies_behind_the_recent_surge_of_amazon_deforestation/2854/
Bill USA
(6,436 posts)http://www.democraticunderground.com/112782298
How the rainforests affect the climate beyond the immediate area of the tropical rainforests is still far from being fully understood. Saving rainforests from significant deforestation could be (probably IS) of extreme importance in the fight against AGW - should we ever decide to actually get serious and engage in that fight.