Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Any New Yorkers here? Who has the best pizza in Manhattan? (Original Post) Flaleftist Jun 2019 OP
Wow, this could be a dangerous thread! PJMcK Jun 2019 #1
Lombardi's is not bad but, dhol82 Jun 2019 #3
I heard the Olive Garden peacefreak2.0 Jun 2019 #2
And truly authentic! 😋🍕 And, all you can eat 🥗🥖! Floyd R. Turbo Jun 2019 #4
Rays Pizza? Famous Rays? Original Rays? Famous Original Rays? nt earthshine Jun 2019 #5
It's just Original, Jerry. nt Codeine Jun 2019 #14
For great pizza in NYC customerserviceguy Jun 2019 #6
Actually, I always preferred the pizza at Captains on Morris Park Avenue dhol82 Jun 2019 #7
When I had it last the Captains was good... DangerousRhythm Jun 2019 #19
My mom always argues it is whistler162 Jun 2019 #9
I've heard that customerserviceguy Jun 2019 #10
I've been to NYC many, many times - even lived there for a while FakeNoose Jun 2019 #16
I do miss customerserviceguy Jun 2019 #17
Forget it! ProudLib72 Jun 2019 #8
Thanks for the suggestions, everyone. Flaleftist Jun 2019 #11
Let us know, OK? FakeNoose Jun 2019 #12
I just had a slice from 7-Eleven and OMG! Flaleftist Jun 2019 #15
You kid, but I know someone who was very excited to tell me... DangerousRhythm Jun 2019 #20
lol nt Flaleftist Jun 2019 #21
Bottom line is this customerserviceguy Jun 2019 #18
I kind of suspected that. The overhead must be insane. Flaleftist Jun 2019 #22
The best pizza this old Texan ever tasted was at Joe's in The Village, years ago. Paladin Jun 2019 #13
The nice thing about Joe's is that you can get fresh mozzarella on your slice. dhol82 Jun 2019 #23

PJMcK

(22,031 posts)
1. Wow, this could be a dangerous thread!
Fri Jun 21, 2019, 08:18 AM
Jun 2019

As a New Yorker since 1976, I'm going to say Lombardi's on Prince Street.

https://www.firstpizza.com

Their food is fresh, delicious and reasonable.

Good luck with this thread!

dhol82

(9,352 posts)
3. Lombardi's is not bad but,
Fri Jun 21, 2019, 08:48 AM
Jun 2019

numéro 28 on Carmine Street is pretty good for a whole pie.
Also Joe’s across from Father Demo Square has decent slices with fresh mozzarella available.
I loathe any pizza described as ‘Tuscan’ - they have no salt in the crust and I find that tasteless.

If you get a chance, do a Scott’s Pizza Tour. The man knows more about pizza than any human I have ever met.

dhol82

(9,352 posts)
7. Actually, I always preferred the pizza at Captains on Morris Park Avenue
Fri Jun 21, 2019, 05:57 PM
Jun 2019

They had a fresh tomato/garlic pizza that was to die for!

DangerousRhythm

(2,916 posts)
19. When I had it last the Captains was good...
Sat Jun 22, 2019, 11:58 PM
Jun 2019

Though I've heard lately the quality has gone down. Not sure if that's true as I haven't had it myself and my tastebuds can't vouch, but it's what I was told recently.

Manhattan pizza is mostly meh, passable enough for me, and I guess I'd go with Patsy's Pizzeria if I had to choose pizza downtown, but if you want the best I'd go with Louie & Ernie's in the Bronx, or Loretta's Pizza, also in the same area. Louie & Ernie's has amazing calzones and white slices -- make sure you get the Manhattan Special -- and Loretta's Pizza has delicious eggplant pizza with balsamic reduction. You just can't go wrong either way.

FakeNoose

(32,633 posts)
16. I've been to NYC many, many times - even lived there for a while
Sat Jun 22, 2019, 11:40 PM
Jun 2019

... and I've had great pizza in a lot of restaurants. But you know what? There are some awesome Italian restaurants in many cities, even in Pittsburgh (where I live now) we have really great pizza.

But I want to say that I've never had authentically awesome calzones anywhere outside of NYC. Nobody knows how to make calzones like the New York Italians. Even the little street vendors that sell calzones at the San Gennaro festival - YUMM!!

customerserviceguy

(25,183 posts)
17. I do miss
Sat Jun 22, 2019, 11:43 PM
Jun 2019

the Italian food in the greater NYC area. But, in Murrells Inlet, we do have "Uncle Mikey's" which makes very good pizza, and really great lasagna!

Still looking for a good bagel down here...

FakeNoose

(32,633 posts)
12. Let us know, OK?
Fri Jun 21, 2019, 11:46 PM
Jun 2019

I'm curious too.

I usually get to the Big Apple once or twice per year, and my son lives on the lower east side.

Flaleftist

(3,473 posts)
15. I just had a slice from 7-Eleven and OMG!
Sat Jun 22, 2019, 10:37 PM
Jun 2019

j/k.

There is some really good food here. Unfortunately, I'm not finding the time to do as much as I wanted to do. I'll definitely come back. I had some obligations/plans that took more time than expected.

Anyway, I think PJ has a point. Now I'm hesitant to judge which ones I think are better than others. I will say I haven't had anything bad yet. I'll PM you about some places later.

DangerousRhythm

(2,916 posts)
20. You kid, but I know someone who was very excited to tell me...
Sun Jun 23, 2019, 12:01 AM
Jun 2019

...that they'd had pizza in NYC like I suggested.

Sbarro's. Times Square.

*facepalm*

customerserviceguy

(25,183 posts)
18. Bottom line is this
Sat Jun 22, 2019, 11:45 PM
Jun 2019

You will probably not find a bad place. A lousy Italian restaurant can exist for two or three years in a lot of places, but in NYC, it won't last two or three months. Eat, enjoy, and abbondanza!

Flaleftist

(3,473 posts)
22. I kind of suspected that. The overhead must be insane.
Sun Jun 23, 2019, 12:38 AM
Jun 2019

I see a few chains manage to exist, mostly supported by visitors who don't know better and maybe a few locals who grew up on them and occasionally want something familiar/nostalgic or for whatever reason.

Paladin

(28,252 posts)
13. The best pizza this old Texan ever tasted was at Joe's in The Village, years ago.
Sat Jun 22, 2019, 08:51 AM
Jun 2019

Had to wait in line for half an hour to get in for lunch. Extraordinary food---hope it's still that good.

dhol82

(9,352 posts)
23. The nice thing about Joe's is that you can get fresh mozzarella on your slice.
Sun Jun 23, 2019, 07:42 AM
Jun 2019

The lines are always insane.
And trying to get counter space to eat is next to impossible.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Any New Yorkers here? Who...