Why America's New Apartment Buildings All Look the Same
The part about parking requirements and the "Texas doughnut" gave me a chuckle.
I didn't get that they covered the lack of difference in design/aesthetics. Still a pretty good read.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-13/why-america-s-new-apartment-buildings-all-look-the-same
Cheap stick framing has led to a proliferation of blocky, forgettable mid-risesand more than a few construction fires.
In the U.S., stick framing appears to have become the default construction method for apartment complexes as well. The big reason is that it costs much lessI heard estimates from 20 percent to 40 percent lessthan building with concrete, steel, or masonry. Those industries have sponsored several studies disputing the gap, but most builders clearly think it exists.
They can also run to the nearest big-box store to find workers. Stick construction allows builders to use cheaper casual labor rather than often-unionized skilled tradespeople. And it makes life easier for electricians, plumbers, and the like because it leaves open spaces through which wires, pipes, and ducts can run. Still, theres a reason why stick wasnt the default for big apartment buildings until recently, and why these buildings are limited in height: Sticks burn.
Yes, the result can be a little repetitive, but repetition has been characteristic of every big new urban or suburban housing trend in the U.S. over the past century or two. Theres lots to like about stumpy buildings that provide new housing in places where its sorely needed and enliven neighborhoods in the process. A four-story Texas doughnut can get 50 or 60 apartments onto an acre of land, while the most aggressively engineered West Coast stick-and-concrete hybrid (two-story podiums are allowed now, along with other variations) can get almost 200. Thats not far from the range that the renowned urbanist Jane Jacobs deemed optimal for vital street life.
Theres also lots to like about building with wood, which, as long as the trees are replanted and allowed to grow to maturity, is now generally accounted to be a net consumer of carbon dioxide. Woods green credentials have helped spur a recent worldwide push for more construction with mass timbersoftwood lumber glued together and compressed into thick beams, columns, and panels. The tallest such structure completed so far is an 18-story dormitory at the University of British Columbia, in Vancouver. Oregon has already changed its code to allow mass timber buildings of that scale, and the 2021 IBC is set to do the same.
dalton99a
(81,426 posts)But it's green
underpants
(182,717 posts)I thought that was a "thing" just maybe 10 years ago? I understood it was a fire safety thing.
highmindedhavi
(355 posts)TreasonousBastard
(43,049 posts)recognized by insurance companies and others as safe. Not "fire proof" which would be ridiculous if even possible, but localizing any fires that break out. Codes keeping up with technology is important.
I remember a fire somewhere around Edgewater, NJ, that was long before the one mentioned in the article. Many details are lost in the fog of memory, but the complex crossed the border between the two tiny towns, and one had tougher codes. The Star-Ledger had an aerial photo after it was over and one half of the complex was burned to the ground while the other half was damaged, but fixable.
Where I am now, safety isn't an issue, but historic districts, waterfront views, parking, and other "trivia" obsess the bureaucracies. And, of course, in a democracy every big mouth has a voice and "NIMBY" isn't just an acronym.
Wellstone ruled
(34,661 posts)And building materials that meet the minimum Code requirements in a given area. Again,the Block Type Construction is the least expensive for any and all of the Mechanical's that are necessary.
dugog55
(296 posts)in America looks the same anymore. Get off an exit of a highway near any town over 5000 people, they are like cookie cutter communities. All the same restaurants, fast food joints and a big mall. Throw in a Sheetz or WaWa and a WalMart, there you go, you are in America. You could have a blindfold removed in a thousand places in this country, and you would have no idea where you were. Every damn place looks the same.