Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

demmiblue

(36,860 posts)
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:17 PM Mar 20

Manchin won't vote for Biden judge picks that lack GOP support

Source: Politico

Joe Manchin has a new rule when it comes to President Joe Biden’s judicial picks: If they don’t have Republican backing, he won’t vote for them.

The retiring West Virginia Democrat has quietly voted against several judicial picks this week, making for some close — though still ultimately successful — votes on the Senate floor. Manchin said there's a method to his opposition.

“Just one Republican. That’s all I’m asking for. Give me something bipartisan. This is my own little filibuster. If they can’t get one Republican, I vote for none. I’ve told [Democrats] that. I said, ‘I’m sick and tired of it, I can’t take it anymore,’” Manchin said in an interview Wednesday.

Manchin’s stance makes party-line nominees even trickier as the election nears, requiring total unanimity among the rest of the 51-member caucus unless a nominee has bipartisan support. At the moment, that might be enough to stop the nomination of Adeel Mangi to an appeals court; Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) came out in opposition to his nomination on Tuesday evening and he has no Republican support at the moment.

Read more: https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2024/03/20/congress/manchin-mounts-his-own-judicial-filibuster-00148147

56 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Manchin won't vote for Biden judge picks that lack GOP support (Original Post) demmiblue Mar 20 OP
Need to bribe some orcas. AnrothElf Mar 20 #1
Can't wait for him to move on Marthe48 Mar 20 #2
I doubt you are going to like the votes by his replacement MichMan Mar 20 #3
So? dchill Mar 20 #5
So, I wouldn't be so gleeful when he leaves MichMan Mar 20 #10
One expects a Republican to act like a Republican. dchill Mar 20 #17
And Schumer is majority leader because unlike a republican onenote Mar 21 #53
Sad but probably true PatSeg Mar 20 #38
Sad but probably true PatSeg Mar 20 #39
jim justice has another lawsuit against him Marthe48 Mar 20 #16
They wont be that much different quakerboy Mar 21 #47
Superego on steroids. dchill Mar 20 #4
Who pays him ? nt DURHAM D Mar 20 #6
What is he sick and tired of? Irish_Dem Mar 20 #7
Exactly. How does he suffer, voting for Democrats? catrose Mar 20 #19
He is so long suffering. Such a victim. Irish_Dem Mar 20 #20
Get lost Manchin Blue Owl Mar 20 #8
Guess he doesn't need to hide his true colors anymore. Think. Again. Mar 20 #9
To hell with you jackass. CousinIT Mar 20 #11
Here's something for you manchin bluestarone Mar 20 #12
Negotiating with 2 year olds isn't practical Raven123 Mar 20 #13
What if we can't find a bipartisan R? What happens then Manchin? RainCaster Mar 20 #14
And the country is sick and tired of Manchin getting media attention Freethinker65 Mar 20 #15
oh screw you Astraea Mar 20 #18
Charles Pierce:"Adeel Mangi Is Hopelessly Qualified for This Judgeship, Not That That Matters Around Here" (he's Muslim) muriel_volestrangler Mar 20 #21
This kind of crap was the reason the founding fathers separated church and state SouthernDem4ever Mar 20 #23
What does "hopelessly overqualified" even mean? niyad Mar 20 #41
"Hopelessly qualified" is a bit of satire, on criticisms of some appointments. Pierce didn't say "over-" muriel_volestrangler Mar 21 #49
How Republican of him to make up new rules and hoops for Dems to jump through ZonkerHarris Mar 20 #22
He is a dick. MOMFUDSKI Mar 20 #24
But he was fine with being the sole Democrat to vote for Kavanaugh. sl8 Mar 20 #25
But he MADE it "bi-partisan" with his OWN vote.... lol DemocraticPatriot Mar 20 #40
Technically true. nt sl8 Mar 21 #52
Fuck. Joe. Manchin. NewHendoLib Mar 20 #26
What a worthless POS. SouthernDem4ever Mar 20 #27
I think Duckworth is still on the fence with this one. Gidney N Cloyd Mar 20 #28
Time to release the Epipen Manchin scandal Kraken. He has more than earned it. GreenWave Mar 20 #29
Doublespeak no_hypocrisy Mar 20 #30
Honorary Republican. OAITW r.2.0 Mar 20 #31
Figures Rebl2 Mar 20 #32
Manchin is a DINO. republianmushroom Mar 20 #33
Corrupt SOB is wanting money. Emile Mar 20 #34
Damned asshole. Hes leaving so why do this at all? The Third Doctor Mar 20 #35
Did Harlan Crowe buy that yacht for Manchin? Midnight Writer Mar 20 #36
What a juvenile LiberalLovinLug Mar 20 #37
He's just showing his ass now Afrocat Mar 20 #42
Does ANYONE in the Senate care about judicial qualification? Thunderbeast Mar 20 #43
Isn't this just so manchin like...good riddance. I know...he's part of our majority, all the same at what cost? PortTack Mar 21 #44
Must make a note to celebrate in fine style Hope22 Mar 21 #45
Take your fake democrat ass samplegirl Mar 21 #46
My grandfather had words for such as Manchin, "He's one bought son-of-a-bitch and that's all he is." jaxexpat Mar 21 #48
I wonder how much the lobbyists are paying him to elect federalist society judges. Mr. Sparkle Mar 21 #50
God Bless Joe Manchin * Oopsie Daisy Mar 21 #51
"I'm sick and tired of it, I can't take it anymore,'" Manchin said" Ray Bruns Mar 21 #54
So he doesn't vote on the merits of the nominee? Just whether a GOPer will support? 617Blue Mar 21 #55
No surprise there. Speaking for myself, I am quite eager for Senator Manchin to retire to his yacht. n/t PatrickforB Mar 21 #56

dchill

(38,502 posts)
17. One expects a Republican to act like a Republican.
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:41 PM
Mar 20

Manchin is supposed to be a Democrat. There's no glee in glad to see him go.

Marthe48

(16,963 posts)
16. jim justice has another lawsuit against him
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:38 PM
Mar 20
https://wvpublic.org/new-lawsuit-names-justice-involves-more-properties-near-greenbrier/

I am in s.e. Ohio right across the river from WV. My husband's family was from WV, and we've always followed the news about the state. I haven't liked any WV politicians since Gaston Caperton.

quakerboy

(13,920 posts)
47. They wont be that much different
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 04:14 AM
Mar 21

But they wont be providing a cloak of "bipartizanship" to cover the illdoing.

The math sucks. But the current reality sucks too.

Irish_Dem

(47,115 posts)
20. He is so long suffering. Such a victim.
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:49 PM
Mar 20

Being asked to vote for THE PEOPLE.
Doing good for Americans.

Sounds like he is so sick of helping people.

RainCaster

(10,880 posts)
14. What if we can't find a bipartisan R? What happens then Manchin?
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:32 PM
Mar 20

He has so little morality when he is closely examined.

muriel_volestrangler

(101,320 posts)
21. Charles Pierce:"Adeel Mangi Is Hopelessly Qualified for This Judgeship, Not That That Matters Around Here" (he's Muslim)
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:49 PM
Mar 20
It’s been a while, but the vague aroma of chickenshit has begun to rise again within the Democratic majority in the U.S. Senate. It was prompted by the confirmation process of Adeel Mangi, a nominee for a seat on the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals. If he’s confirmed, Mangi would be the first Muslim ever appointed to that level of the federal judiciary. In a hearing last December, he was subjected to a level of outright Islamophobia by the Senate Judiciary Committee’s Republicans that would, in the late Molly Ivins’s immortal phrase, gag a maggot. And now, CNN tells us, the Democrats in the Senate are making sure their white flags are nice and crisp and starchy.
...
At one point during Mangi’s confirmation hearing before the judiciary panel in December, Texas Republican Sen. Ted Cruz highlighted Mangi’s connection to the Center for Security, Race and Rights at Rutgers University–a group that Cruz said embraces “extremism and myopia” and has expressed antisemitic views. Mangi said he had served on the center’s advisory board, which met once a year and advised on areas of academic research, and that he had no knowledge of any events or speakers that the group might have hosted. “Do you condemn the atrocities of the Hamas terrorists?” Cruz asked. “The events of October 7 were a horror involving the deaths of innocent civilians,” Mangi responded. Pressed by the Texas Republican on whether there was any justification for the October 7 attacks, Mangi said: “I have no patience, none, for any attempts to justify or defend those events.”

Tailgunner Ted was not the only one taking his bigotry out for a walk that day. Judd Legum’s Popular Information has been dogging this story for a while now, and it was careful to chronicle the unfolding ethical and moral calamity. Senator Jubilation T. Cornpone weighed in with his usual performative hay-shaking routine.

Senator John Kennedy (R-LA), not to be outdone, asked Mangi if he “celebrate[s] 9/11.” Mangi addressed that smear directly. “I don’t think anyone can feel more strongly about what happened on 9/11 than someone who was there…I was in New York. I saw what happened. It was my city,” Mangi said. “I will condemn, without equivocation, any terrorism, any terrorist, any act of terrorism, or any defense of any act of terrorism.”

Unsurprisingly, Senator Lindsey Graham leaped onto the bandwagon, as did Senator Mike Lee, the konztitooshnal skolar from Utah. Both submitted written questions along the same foul theme. Graham distinguished himself by grilling Mangi on events that occurred after he had left the Rutgers center and on meetings that he did not attend. Outside observers were revolted by the spectacle.

The ADL said that “Mangi was subjected to aggressive questioning unrelated to his professional expertise or qualifications” and “was forced to provide responses to a wide range of inquiries regarding his views on global strategic considerations in a manner that inappropriately politicized these issues and raised serious questions regarding pretext and bias.” The ADL concluded that “berating the first American Muslim federal appellate judicial nominee with endless questions that appear to have been motivated by bias towards his religion is profoundly wrong.” The American Jewish Committee, the National Council of Jewish Women, and numerous other Jewish organizations also denounced the tactics used against Mangi.


https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a60254213/biden-nominated-adeel-mangi-circuit-court-appeals/

So this is the result of Cortez Masto and Manchin's cowardice: they enable the Republicans' Islamophobia - and you don't have to be Muslim to see it.

SouthernDem4ever

(6,617 posts)
23. This kind of crap was the reason the founding fathers separated church and state
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 06:59 PM
Mar 20

Repuglicans don't care about the constitution. As long as someone can rule only with regard to the law and not their religion, it isn't an issue. Unfortunately some right wing judges can't seem to grasp this concept.

muriel_volestrangler

(101,320 posts)
49. "Hopelessly qualified" is a bit of satire, on criticisms of some appointments. Pierce didn't say "over-"
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 05:56 AM
Mar 21

Mangi is very well qualified for the position, but that means nothing to Republicans, because he's Muslim.

sl8

(13,786 posts)
25. But he was fine with being the sole Democrat to vote for Kavanaugh.
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 07:01 PM
Mar 20

Guess bipartisanship wasn't an issue when he voted for the Trump nominee.

SouthernDem4ever

(6,617 posts)
27. What a worthless POS.
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 07:07 PM
Mar 20

His political ambitions after he leaves the senate must be to lobby with repuglicans or some other stupid anti-democracy bullshit.

no_hypocrisy

(46,117 posts)
30. Doublespeak
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 08:17 PM
Mar 20

On one hand, Joe Manchin wants bipartisan support for democratic judges. He wants republican backing.

But on the other hand, all that would satisfy Manchin is just one, solitary republican vote. One single vote.


Since when does ONE arbitrary vote signify bipartisanship and support by Republicans?

The Third Doctor

(241 posts)
35. Damned asshole. Hes leaving so why do this at all?
Wed Mar 20, 2024, 09:15 PM
Mar 20

He's been mostly useless anyway. Neither the gop or Dems give a damn about it.

PortTack

(32,771 posts)
44. Isn't this just so manchin like...good riddance. I know...he's part of our majority, all the same at what cost?
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 02:01 AM
Mar 21

We all argued that at least president Biden was getting judges appointed…now this

So what good is he?

Hope22

(1,840 posts)
45. Must make a note to celebrate in fine style
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 02:24 AM
Mar 21

When this boil moves on. I am tired of hearing what he will do and not do. Go home and leave us in peace!

jaxexpat

(6,831 posts)
48. My grandfather had words for such as Manchin, "He's one bought son-of-a-bitch and that's all he is."
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 05:52 AM
Mar 21

But the road to sanctification, like the road to perdition, is long, but the faithful, and fearful, persevere.

Mr. Sparkle

(2,933 posts)
50. I wonder how much the lobbyists are paying him to elect federalist society judges.
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 06:15 AM
Mar 21

It must be a lot if he is willing to vote against his party's own picks.

Oopsie Daisy

(2,629 posts)
51. God Bless Joe Manchin *
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 06:16 AM
Mar 21

* because he helps Democrats to retain control of the Senate (and his replacement will be an Republican who will help to give the GOP control.) Regardless of how he votes, we are lucky to have him, aren't we?

Look for the silver lining and count our blessings, my momma always said.

Ray Bruns

(4,098 posts)
54. "I'm sick and tired of it, I can't take it anymore,'" Manchin said"
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 08:19 AM
Mar 21

Then quit you piece of shit. You’re not going to get a republican to vote for a Biden nominee.

617Blue

(1,279 posts)
55. So he doesn't vote on the merits of the nominee? Just whether a GOPer will support?
Thu Mar 21, 2024, 08:41 AM
Mar 21

That's a logically indefensible position. He and Sinema never make any sense.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Manchin won't vote for Bi...