General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe judge calling for a return to the guillotine
Impeachment is slower, but not as messy.
The judge calling for a return to the guillotine
Ninth Circuit Appeals Court Judge Alex Kozinski holds provocative views on the death penalty. In an interview with Lesley Stahl this week, he advocates for the firing squad even the guillotine.
Its 100 percent effective, and it leaves no doubt that what we are doing is a violent thing, he tells Stahl on the broadcast.
But look past the shocking sentiment and French Revolution imagery and see Judge Kozinskis broader notion: killing a person no matter how its carried out and how legally justified courts deem it is vicious.
If were going to take human life, if were going to execute people, if the state is going to snuff out a human being, he says, we should not fool ourselves into thinking that its anything but a violent, brutal act.
Warpy
(111,456 posts)gushing blood, severed heads and twitching torsos or hiding the extreme violence of the state toward the worst citizens by masking it with drugs. Personally, I'd prefer the latter, but only if they chose better drugs.
PJMcK
(22,069 posts)I am totally opposed to the death penalty. Our government should not commit this murderous act in our names.
However, if the States and the Federal Government are going to do this, it should be public and demonstrably brutal. They are acting on our behalf and our governments need to be transparent. After all, one of the strongest arguments death penalty advocates make is that capital punishment acts as a deterrent. Fine. Show it so people will be deterred. If the killing is sanitized and hidden behind curtains, how will anyone get the message?
In the interview, Judge Alex Kozinski says:
Egnever
(21,506 posts)If we are ending peoples lives pretending it is kind is ridiculous.
LongTomH
(8,636 posts)"Jeebus, they wanna chop this poor bastard's head off!!!!"
Maybe then, they would be more amenable to choosing a sentence of life without parole.
Pacifist Patriot
(24,654 posts)ProudLib72
(17,984 posts)We use drugs to hide the brutality of it. Beheading or firing squad would be more humane for the victim, but it would expose the truth of what is actually being done -- murder.
Ilsa
(61,712 posts)Middle east nations for employing beheading? Why is what ISIS doing worse than blowing people ?
AngryAmish
(25,704 posts)There is no comparison, my friend. Trust me.
angstlessk
(11,862 posts)He doesn't WANT beheading, he doesn't want the death penalty at all, but if you are doing it, make it brutal for all to realize how barbaric it really is.
cstanleytech
(26,357 posts)the death penalty rather I suspect that it would become our modern day version of the gladiatorial games with alot of people anticipating the beheadings with a voracious bloodlust.
angstlessk
(11,862 posts)Ilsa
(61,712 posts)And I didn't refer to him, but others.
retrowire
(10,345 posts)It works on those who don't think hard enough. And I wonder sometimes if it's necessary. I don't like fearmongering people into changing their minds but... Killing is monstrous. Do people not know this?
WoonTars
(694 posts)Do it publicly so that people can see what cold-blooded killing looks like.