General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsPolice murder in Perkasie Pa
Matt Coughlin Staff Writer Phillyburbs.com
Posted on July 30, 2012
by Matt Coughlin
Perkasie police erred in shooting and killing a handcuffed man, but it wasn't a crime, according to the Bucks County District Attorneys Office.
Michael Marino Jr., 26, posed a danger to the officers after they arrested him behind an abandoned building next to railroad tracks in Sellersville on June 9, DA David Heckler said Monday. But he also called into question several tactical decisions made at the scene that led to the fatal altercation.
And, Heckler said charging the officer who shot Marino, Seth Mumbauer, with manslaughter, would be making him a scapegoat for society's decisions.
According to the Bucks County Detectives' reports filed with the DA's office, Marino, of Quakertown, was handcuffed and seated on an embankment when the sergeant on duty that day stepped away to call for an ambulance. An officer started patting down Marino, who began yelling gibberish and flailing, police said. That officer and Mumbauer began struggling with Marino, who kicked down one officer. After being repeatedly kicked, Mumbauer was able to step free, pull his gun and shoot Marino.
They shot and killed a man in handcuffs. A man with mental illness and a drug problem. No charges are being filed. Was the officer tested for steroids? No answer. He got mad and shot a person yet he walks.
Can you believe that excuse. It is societies fault that the cop lost his temper and shot the person.
I am sick
mike_c
(36,281 posts)"...a scapegoat for society's decisions." That is beyond lame.
Scootaloo
(25,699 posts)Archae
(46,364 posts)Being handcuffed doesn't always mean someone is harmless.
And this guy was out of his mind.
Fumesucker
(45,851 posts)There are other options besides shooting a handcuffed person..
Archae
(46,364 posts)The full article with link:
Perkasie police erred in shooting and killing a handcuffed man, but it wasn't a crime, according to the Bucks County District Attorneys Office.
Michael Marino Jr., 26, posed a danger to the officers after they arrested him behind an abandoned building next to railroad tracks in Sellersville on June 9, DA David Heckler said Monday. But he also called into question several tactical decisions made at the scene that led to the fatal altercation.
And, Heckler said charging the officer who shot Marino, Seth Mumbauer, with manslaughter, would be making him a scapegoat for society's decisions.
According to the Bucks County Detectives' reports filed with the DA's office, Marino, of Quakertown, was handcuffed and seated on an embankment when the sergeant on duty that day stepped away to call for an ambulance. An officer started patting down Marino, who began yelling gibberish and flailing, police said. That officer and Mumbauer began struggling with Marino, who kicked down one officer. After being repeatedly kicked, Mumbauer was able to step free, pull his gun and shoot Marino.
Authorities said Marino had stopped taking mental health medication before the incident, that synthetic marijuana was found in his system and white plastic beads, which he had swallowed, were found in his stomach.
http://www.phillyburbs.com/news/crime/da-shooting-not-criminal-never-should-have-happened/article_e93a9b2c-5a15-573c-b941-f5a4418d9354.html
Fumesucker
(45,851 posts)No such thing unless the guy was taking Marinol, which is quite expensive (considerably more so than the real thing), requires a prescription, is actually synthetic THC and comes in a capsule..
Sounds like bullshit to me and definitely makes me suspect the rest of the story..
Archae
(46,364 posts)Fumesucker
(45,851 posts)So that part of the story *is* bullshit just as I suspected..
Archae
(46,364 posts)He would have been mellowed out, not freaking out on someone's weird concoction of chemicals.
DiverDave
(4,890 posts)next?
Pretty bs if you ask me, you think they did the right thing?
HiPointDem
(20,729 posts)1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)I wonder what "societal decision" the DA is referring to? It being more cost-effective to shoot and kill a mentally ill drug addict, than arrest, house and daresay I, provide treatment?
raouldukelives
(5,178 posts)Earth_First
(14,910 posts)You know, they *new* civilian law enforcement department....
JrsyGirl
(1 post)Here's a history of "death by Cop" in Bucks County.
http://www.phillyburbs.com/my_town/pennridge/no-word-on-sellersville-shooting-ruling/article_6c5b31c8-8010-5380-90df-117fb503652f.html
It's interesting how the ten page report shows pictures of the scene, but no pictures of Marino's swollen wrists from the handcuffs. No pictures of the officer bruised jaw. A cop shoots and kills, then weaves a story as to why he was in fear of his life- a kick to the groin and jaw. But, no so much in fear that back up wasn't called. Also, witness statements were given almost immediately. Cops statements were given over 10 days later, after all three cops met and re enacted the scene together, without independent council. What happened to - pull them aside separately within hours of the incident and interview? Truth doesn't need collaboration.
June 18th- NJ cop, went to same district, armed with enough weapons to take a neighborhood down, shot at police, had a bullet proof vest on... and was "negotiated" to safety.
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504083_162-57455142-504083/doylestown-shooting-richard-klementovich-off-duty-nj-cop-faces-attempted-homicide-charges-after-standoff-with-police/
Difference? The Perkasie cop is notorious for his temper/harassment of citizens. The big bad 6'7" 200 lb cop, standing on solid ground was furious that a 5'6" 135 lb cuffed and sitting on unstable embankment kicked him in the groin.
guest0429
(2 posts)Umm... They have two different outcomes because they were two different situations. Mumbauer is not "known for his temper/harassment". Yes... I know this for fact. You're basing that comment off Marinos family and friends statements. None of them live in perkasie or sellersville to have ever come in contact with him. Marino kicked him in the groin and in the jaw. That wouldn't knock you for a loop? Marino then stood up and lunged at mumbauer. Did you forget to read that part? He was also 160lbs... Not 135lbs.
The doylestown situation?! That was a depressed and crazy cop from jersey. They were shooting at him! They were ordered to kill him if need be. He just lucked out that he didn't get hit.
The news reporters were the one who got the witness accounts firsthand... Gee... Wonder if that's why they came out first? One more thing... Why should they show you the autopsy pics of Marinos wrists, or the bruising of the cops face? Did you stop to think that maybe its sealed evidence?
Iggo
(47,583 posts)They're the best!