General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNorth Dakota girl bullied to death---Her obituary didn't hold anything back.
Bob CollinsBob Collins April 4, 2018, 7:05 AM 24 Comments
A 12-year-old girl took her own life in Bismarck, N.D., on Saturday.
Cherish Chance was born on July 17, 2005, in Minot, ND, to Nathan Houle and Jessica Chiefstick. She grew up in Minot and began attending school there. In 2009, Cherish and her family moved to Bismarck where she continued her education in Bismarck. Most recently, she was attending the 7th grade in Bismarck.
Cherish was an uplifting person to be around, always concerned for the well-being of those around her. She always had a smile on her face and loved nothing more than to make people laugh. Cherish was very close to her family and enjoyed talking to people about her siblings and parents and loved them deeply. She loved to draw and listen to music.
Cherish experienced intense pain most people her age will never know. Throughout the last 6 months of her life, she experienced continual transition and intense bullying at school. While the news is currently highlighting violence as the result of bullying. Cherishs support systems saw a very different result. Those who loved Cherish didnt know how unbearable that pain she was experiencing had become for her. The support and love she was able to receive from those around her wasnt enough to heal the scars of the relentless bullying she had already suffered. Cherish didnt harm others or turn to drugs and alcohol to deal with her pain, she took her life on March 31st, 2018.
The word bullying doesnt begin to encompass ugliness and pain it causes. The ugly truth of bullying is someone who loved Cherish had to open the bedroom door and see what they saw on Saturday. The ugly truth of bullying is those who loved Cherish cant close their eyes at night because they cant get the image out of their head. The ugly truth of bullying is doing CPR for 4 minutes and 26 seconds. Its listening to 911 operator tell you to go faster and push harder. Its knowing that you didnt open the door early enough for it to matter anyway. Its that Cherish isnt here anymore.
The Houle/Chiefstick family lost a beautiful member of their family. Cherish was a beautiful soul who no longer has to suffer pain and rejection here on Earth.
Cherishs family and support systems want the public to be aware of her situation in hopes that it will prevent tragedies such as this from occurring again. They are asking that parents talk to their children and find out answers to hard question. Are they being bullied? Are they the bully? Have they witnessed bullying and it broke their heart, but they were glad they werent the target today? Did they not know what to do and walked away? Or joined in the laughter because they didnt want to attract the attention of other bullies in the crowd. We are asking you to teach your children that our words are our most powerful resource and we need to be careful to use that precious resource to positively affect people. Teach your children what to do if someone they know is talking about suicide. Teach them who to call for help.
To those of you who were kind to Cherish, thank you. Your love and acceptance meant the world to her. To Cherish, thank you for coming into all our lives. We are all much better for it. Fly high and carry our love forever. You will be greatly missed.
She is survived by her mom, Jessica; her dad, Nathan; siblings, Santana, Sonte, Maliyah, Nathan Jr., and Yuri; her grandmas, Marina Cheifstick and Judy Nelson; and many aunts, uncles, and cousins.
She was preceded in death by her grandpas, Leon Houle and Noble Mooseamen; her aunts, Deena and Kristen; and her uncle, Leslie.
Visitation will be held Thursday, April 5, 2018, from 10am-12 Noon at Eastgate Funeral Service, 2302 E Divide Ave., in Bismarck, ND.
(h/t: Kari Knudson)
https://blogs.mprnews.org/newscut/2018/04/north-dakota-girl-bullied-to-death/
B2G
(9,766 posts)CatMor
(6,212 posts)why has this country become even more cruel than it was in the past. trump is taking us further down.
MichMary
(1,714 posts)Bullying has been a serious problem forever, and there have been kids who have killed themselves, and many, many more who want to.
For those who survive childhood bullying, sometimes the effects are lifelong. I read a book some years ago entitled Odd Girl Out that talked about that very thing.
CatMor
(6,212 posts)but with the internet and social media it has become more wide spread now.
infullview
(982 posts)Back in the day, if you were going to be bullied, people had to do it to your face. Others either joined in, watched, or supported you and helped you fight back. In this new environment, bullying is more anonymous, and people tend to 'pile-on'; people who are being bullied don't often seek support from their friends. I'm sure it can be very lonely and isolating. My condolences to this poor family. I can't imagine how hard it must be for them.
CatMor
(6,212 posts)Moostache
(9,897 posts)Yes, I realize that Trump has no direct connection to this poor little girl's fate and her family's agony...but his very presence and modus operandi are built entirely on a foundation of this exact kind of behavior. He gives license to the worst elements of humanity through his own behavior and statements and actions.
I mourn her fate and send well wishes to her family and survivors everywhere suffering today...but I curse the very air that allows Trump to breathe and wish he would be the one to suffer and commit suicide instead of innocent little girls or boys in anonymous pain and torment.
7962
(11,841 posts)You even see it here sometimes; people eager to speak down to other posters with whom they disagree.
I remember dealing with it as a kid decades ago. I was in a military family and never started school at the beginning of the year. So the "new kid" always gets picked on. I was lucky enough to be able to ignore it and overcome some of it with humor. Others had a much harder time.
Today it wouldn't stop when school was over, it continues on Facebook or twitter or texts, etc
lunasun
(21,646 posts)smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)And that there are children out there who are cruel enough to drive her to do it. RIP Cherish.
HipChick
(25,485 posts)sarisataka
(18,857 posts)At an all school assembly with parents in attendance
jmowreader
(50,572 posts)They would consider it a great victory that they bullied someone to death.
I hate society. All this fucking "anti bullying" stuff is nothing more than giving the governor a harrumph. We ran a story about one of the local schools' anti-bullying campaign. The premise of the whole thing was, "if we tell the bullies we don't like bullying, they'll stop." Wrong, wrong and terribly wrong: they're bullying BECAUSE you don't like it.
sarisataka
(18,857 posts)because it won't work anyway?
I don't accept that answer. I have been to too many funerals of teenagers, younger children and young adults who took their lives to accept that answer.
I often see people say after a school shooting "they should have just killed themselves first". Well here is what that looks like. A victim pushed to the breaking point will lash out, sometimes at others but far more often at themselves.
I will not consider this a win because there is only one victim. I will also not blow it off saying nothing can be done.
Bullies bully because they can, because there are no meaningful consequences. If bullying is met head on, the bullies faces punishment for their actions, the parents are required to be involved it will change. Until these things are done, there will be victims. Whether it is seventeen all at once, in a national story or seventeen individual tragedies that rarely get more than local notice- it will continue to happen.
MichMary
(1,714 posts)7962
(11,841 posts)Not sure how to accomplish that; maybe make them pick up trash in front of the rest of the school. Fine the parents. SOMETHING.
Agree wholeheartedly with your message but I would go further.
The most important target of anti-bullying efforts are the bystanders. If you move some of the bystanders from passive observers to active defenders, it changes the dynamic completely. Both in the way that the bullies act and the way the victims feel. Bullies are cowards and want to pick on the weak and defenseless with mob at their back. Remove the mob or defend the victim and they will scurry away like the cowards they are.
Oppaloopa
(867 posts)saidsimplesimon
(7,888 posts)Children who are bullies often have a parent who is a bully. Most relgious, Home Schooled and Alt-Right private schools are already
mandating this kind of thing, praising rump and ignoring the fact this nation was founded on the absolute principal of separation of Church and state, The Rule of Law and the principles of Democracy.
Initech
(100,121 posts)get the red out
(13,468 posts)Bullies are NOT good people.
usaf-vet
(6,231 posts)presidential bullies. Just look at the current resident in the White House. Just listen to his speeches (racist rants).
Achilleaze
(15,543 posts)a beautiful child bullied to death. Where the Hell was republican immigrant Melania, spouse of Dirty Donny*? She claimed she was going to do something about bullying. But that was a lie. She is married to a bully, who is the role model for a whole emerging generation of punk republican bullies. Sick and sad.
* republican Draft-Dodger-in-Chief
Initech
(100,121 posts)That's all they do - lie, cheat, steal, and bully. You can see evidence of that 24 hours a day on AM radio. It's on Fox News. Just watch Sean Hannity - he's a professional bully. So is Rush Limbaugh, Ann Coulter, Geraldo Rivera, Laura Ingraham, Michael Savage, I could go on and on - that's all they do. And kids learn it from their parents. We can't change the culture unless we're willing to change and it's not something that can be solved overnight. And having a president who is a professional bully like Trump - and there have been hundreds of documented cases of evidence since the inauguration about Trump related bullying and the school administrators simply don't know what to do, because he's the president. It's scary and until we change that expect things to remain the same or get worse.
GallopingGhost
(2,404 posts)any time acting hurt or indignant when someone says something about her son, but she didn't, and doesn't have a word to say when her orange sugar daddy mocked a disabled man, or when he verbally abuses and bullies people on a daily basis on Twitter. Donald Trump, hero of bullies everywhere.
Anti-bullying platform. Look up the word irony, madam. What a joke.
RIP, sweet girl.
Farmer-Rick
(10,222 posts)And sex worker to get ahead.
Sugar daddies are the basis of their retirement plans.
Ilsa
(61,709 posts)She needs to see it.
I just did that
peace,
kp
caballojm
(273 posts)Yes, I know bullying existed long before them, but these scum are normalizing and encouraging this kind of behavior. Things will get worse as long as people continue to pay attention to these a$$h@les.
MichMary
(1,714 posts)when Phoebe Prince hanged herself in 2010?
Blaming Trump, or any other president, lets the bullies off the hook. THEY are responsible, and THEY need to be held accountable for their actions.
mvd
(65,180 posts)Definitely hateful incidents have been up in schools. And a bully sets an example for other bullies. Sure, the bully is at fault, but Trump isn't helping anything.
MichMary
(1,714 posts)that we had for eight years, but I don't necessarily think that all that many young people look to the POTUS as an example. Most teenagers really aren't that tuned into politics. As many have said here, I think bullying has gotten to be worse because of social media.
mvd
(65,180 posts)of immigrant children, minorities, etc. The kids hear stuff from their parents.
caballojm
(273 posts)But if you're still unconvinced of Orange Caligula's influence and culpability: [link:https://bit.ly/2q855tZ| and [link:https://bit.ly/2En0xV7|
Bettie
(16,139 posts)but this guy is not normal.
He's given far too many people explicit permission to be the worst versions of themselves, by his example of self-indulgent and dishonest (and far more) living.
He has personally contributed to this atmosphere. It has gotten worse since the election, I see it in my teenage boys' school.
loyalsister
(13,390 posts)for having cheered on the assaults on MSNBC as much as others who have given rise to and participated in the conflict driven media that rules cable news and has infiltrated our mainstream culture. This is on all of us and we should not be surprised that it has escalated. The hard question is what do we do about? I have no answers, but I feel obligated to recognize that it is a broader socially problem that is of all of our own making.
cp
(6,673 posts)Loving family
To you we send our love
Fly high, Cherish
cungar2000
(98 posts)I still ask her all the time if anyone's picked on her.
I had a guy punch me in the back every day for an entire semester when I was in 7th grade. The teacher never did a damn thing about it.
woodsprite
(11,938 posts)I told people, but they just said "It's because he likes you." He would say nasty things, insults, call me names in front of his friends, then laugh at me, and at times, snap my bra straps (he sat behind me in class). I talked to the teacher and she said "He does it because he likes you. I'll talk with him, but you should be glad you have enough to wear a c-cup. I'd give anything to have what you have." That did nothing to solve the problem or make a busty 5th grade introvert feel better.
One winter day, I had enough. He always followed me home from school. We lived on the same street. He took my hat and put it in the old fashioned mail box. I warned him. He made fun of my warning. I hauled off and clocked him upside the head with my loaded book bag. He went home with a bloody ear and had to eventually fess up to his mother about how it all happened.
In my case, I was the one that had to bring about the situation to make the bully account for his actions. Today, from the most I can tell, nobody in authority does that, and most kids are too stressed, too afraid of punishment either from parents or the system. They are internalizing it all, unable to speak or stick up for themselves, and blaming themselves for something that is totally someone elses problem.
Luciferous
(6,086 posts)I have always told my kids they will never get in trouble for defending themselves.
geardaddy
(24,931 posts)I wonder if the bullies were white kids and bullied her because she was Native.
TexasBushwhacker
(20,229 posts)The name change and the short haircut makes me wonder if she was trans.
Angry Dragon
(36,693 posts)sl8
(13,949 posts)Last edited Thu Apr 5, 2018, 08:17 PM - Edit history (1)
In addition to the bullying issue, this article points out possible problems in her foster home. Doesn't mention why she was in foster care.
From http://www.myndnow.com/news/bismarck-news/death-by-suicide-of-a-bismarck-preteen-draws-attention-to-bullying/1102173448
Summer said she noticed a difference in Cherish, who changed her name to Chance.
She was being bullied at school and was having issues in her foster home and became withdrawn.
...
Her family says bullying wasn't the only challenging issue Cherish faced.
"It wasn't just bullying, but there was home problems to and growing up it was a tough situation. If I would've gotten a hold of her and told her that her dad's going to be home soon within the end of this month, I think it would've probably changed her mind and everything on this outcome," said Nelson.
...
world wide wally
(21,758 posts)This is a tragedy that has been repeated far too often. I even had some bullying in my senior year at Catholic high school. But it gets much worse than what I ever experienced, and there are more ways to do it now.
BobTheSubgenius
(11,572 posts)I don't mean to minimize her suffering, or that of any other victim of bullying, but I do want to ask - what has changed? Is it the way social media reaches into everyone's lives? Are the bullies gaining new forms of emotional sadism on the Internet?
Like everyone else, I remember kids being bullied, some relentlessly, many, at least a little. I don't remember even one committing suicide. I know that it's a tiny sample size, and really no more than anecdotal evidence, but still.
Perhaps parents were more connected to their children's lives, lo those many years ago? I'm not blaming anyone, I'm legitimately perplexed by this.
MichMary
(1,714 posts)Social media. It used to be that you could go home from school and, at least for the evening, shut the bullies out; but now, it's always there.
Was just reading an article this a.m. that depression rates in young people started to rise sharply in 2012, which was about the same time kids started getting smart phones. Not a coincidence, I'm sure.
PatrickforO
(14,602 posts)especially, that were bullied horribly. One girl named Ann, who was almost blind and had to wear glasses with Coke bottle lenses was harassed every day of her life by a group of mean kids. A boy named Bill who suffered so badly tears would be rolling down his cheeks by the time the bus hit his stop in the afternoon. A kid named Kenny who was very mildly retarded and and skinny dark-haired kid named Kirk.
Children can be very, very cruel. I don't know what happened to these four people - it was so long ago. But I'm sure that, if they are still alive, they carry the scars of this thoughtless, needless cruelty.
PatrickforO
(14,602 posts)a plastic butter knife to school, she would be immediately expelled due to 'zero-tolerance' 'zero common sense' policies.
Silly me, I'd think that unrelenting bullying is more dangerous than a plastic butter knife.
As to Jessica, Nathan and family, please accept my heartfelt condolences for your beloved Cherish. I'm so very sorry for your loss.
kchamberlin25
(84 posts)Was tutored at home for about three months. Was never able to run or play sports well afterwords. I was ruthlessly bullied well into high school by one young man mainly, although others joined in. I always scored well on intelligence tests, but was generally too timid to have much success at anything. I dropped out of college, had a series of low paying jobs for most of my life, and married an abusive woman at age thirty who fortunately walked out on me less than a year later. I am now married to an angel, and we have twins who just turned 20, both of whom are excelling at college. I had a heart attack in 2014, and am now on disability, so I at least don't have to work any more.
Don't get me wrong, I don't blame others for my difficulties...
But it's hard not to wonder what might have been.